Comparison of Two Poems

Topics: Disgust, Exclamation mark, Exclamation Pages: 3 (1156 words) Published: September 21, 2009
In two of D.H Lawrence’s works Bat and Man and Bat, both poems portray the author’s encounters with bats and his feeling of disgust towards them. In this essay I will compare the two poems in terms of tone, rhythm, diction and style. Both Bat and Man and bat started with a peaceful tone; the author describes the setting in Florence, Italy and gives a calming tone to the readers. However, as the author proceeds with the poem, and starts to introduce a bat, the tone starts to change. In bat, the tone changes gradually, the author wonders why a swallow would fly so late- at this point he describes the swallow’s movement and the tone changes; the readers sense a mysterious feel. When the author does confirm that the bird is in fact a bat, the tone of the poem changes, we sense the disgust the author feels towards the bats, using words such as “old rag”, giving “uneasy creeping in one’s scalp” (341-342). This particular tone set by the author greatly defines the hate he has for bats and also due to change in rhythm and diction, helps the readers experience the events within the poem. However, the tone in Man and Bat did not change as gradually, in fact it changes drastically. Soon after the start of the poem, the author introduces the bat and almost immediately words such as “disgusting” and “Out! Go Out!” (342) sets the tone of disgust. Throughout the ‘rant’ the tone remains the same, but the author did change the tone twice; when the main character in the poem (supposedly the author) realizes that the bat cannot leave his room because he cannot face the light, a sense of pity clouds the readers, the author feels pit for the bat and changes the mood slightly for a while. The tone of disgust returns though soon after yet it changes again; whilst the author wants to kill the bat and throw it away, he said that he didn’t create the bat therefore he cannot kill it, the tone shifts back to pity for the second time, giving the readers more hints that the author does...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Essay on A Comparison of Two Poems
  • Comparison Between Two Poems Essay
  • Essay on Comparison of Two Love Poems
  • A Comparison of Two Poems Essay
  • Comparison of Two Death Oriented Poems Essay
  • Essay on A Comparison of Two Poems by Emily Dickinson
  • Comparison of Two Poems: 'the Tyger' and 'the Lamb' Essay
  • Comparison of Two Poems Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free