The Magna Carta and the Petition of Rights are very important in the history of England that both of them are significant to the development of England. They have similarities and differences. In my opinion, both of these two were put forward to limit the crown of the King. And both of them were signed by the King who were forced to sign them. What is more, both of them were abandoned by the King at last, but they also had very important effects on the development of England. Now let me show my opinions of their differences to you. The Magna Carta (1215) was the constitutional document which was signed by the King John, who was forced to sign it. The purpose of the document was to ensure the independence of the policy and the rights and interests of the economy of the feudal lords. And it is also bad for energizing the crown. The document was the first one that limits the power of the seignior, and the cornerstone of the English Constitution Monarchy. The Magna Carta had 63 items and most of the contents ensured the rights and interests of the feudal lord, the most important effect of it was to limit the crown. With the strengthen of the crown in 15 or 16 century, the Magna Carta was ignored. But during the English Bourgeois Revolution, the bourgeoisie gave it new sense to fight the crown of the feudalism and it finally became one of the most important parts of the Constitution of the United Kingdom. The Petition of Rights actually was signed by the King, who was forced to signed it because of he need the military expenditure to engine on the foreign wars. The Petition of Rights was also the successful result of the fight which the congress fought against the King for liberty and rights. And it was the first Bill of Rights in the history of England. Generally speaking, the main purpose of the Petition of Rights was to limit the crown of the King and to protect the personal liberty and the safety of the property of the subjects of the feudal ruler. The Magna Carta was put forward to improve the position of the congress and to limit the crown of the King. The key note of it was that it formed a finite monarchy. The Petition of Rights was put forward because of the reign of the Stuarts in England limited the development of the capitalism. The focal point was the problem of levy. The contents of the Petition of Rights was similar to the Magna Carta, but the Petition of Rights stock up the rights and interests of the new feudal lords and the bourgeoisie.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The Bill of Rights has a long history entangled with that of the American Constitution. The first Congress has achieved more than any other congress in American history, they not only have the credits of a successful organization of the government, of law, administration, and defense but the enactment of the American Bill of Rights. The original Constitution of 1787 contained several provisions of major significance for civil liberties, however did not contain a specific bill of rights. This failure to incorporate a bill of rights by the framers of the constitution was not a sign of resentment or lack of concern to the rights of man, but rather their certainty that particular guarantees of rights was unnecessary. However this did not satisfy some states, who deeply demanded for solemn assurances that the new government would not consent to exercise tyranny, therefore a debate between the Federalist and Anti-Federalist began.…
- 3046 Words
- 8 Pages
Good Essays -
My reading notes state “Government couldn’t take away person life, liberty, or property.” This has affected our government today because even though back then life was much tougher we still follow these rules today and now even more due to the Constitution which gives many rights. The reading when talking about the Magna Carta says “Some of these rights established a system of justice based on due process of law.” This has impacted our present government because without this we wouldn’t have the justice system we have today and the fact that we have fair trials determining if the person is guilty or innocent to determine punishment. This is why the Magna Carta was the most influential agreement to our modern…
- 567 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Freedom from England’s tyranny is what the colonists wanted so they could have a say in the government. Comparative Studies in Freedom from Democracy Webb states “‘The most fundamental concept of democracy...secure the rights of the people,’” (document C) because the colonists…
- 455 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The Declaration of Independence states that the purpose of the government (in terms of the social contract) that selected leaders and people are to ensure the protection of their rights and that they won't be taken away from them. If they happen to feel that they are not getting their proper protection, they are able to abolish it and create a new one... These were the things that the King had violated.…
- 463 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
It is apparent that all was not well in England in the years building up to the Magna Carta in 1215. The barons of the day, not royalty, but the upper crust of society, forced King John to sign the document because it greatly reduced the power he held as the King of England and allowed for the formation of a powerful parliament. In return, the barons took an oath of loyalty to King John under the agreement that all abide by it. The Magna Carta became the basis for English citizen's rights and it is evidence that the people of England faced many political, social, economic, and ethnic tensions with King John and his empire.…
- 626 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The Magna Carta is a document that King John of England (1166 - 1216) was forced into signing. King John was forced into signing the charter because it greatly reduced the power he held as the King of England and allowed for the formation of a powerful parliament. The Magna Carta became the basis for English citizen's rights. The purpose of the Magna Carta was to curb the King and make him govern by the old English laws that had prevailed before the Normans came. The Magna Carta was a collection of 37 English laws - some copied, some recollected some old and some new. The Magna Carta demonstrated that the power of the king could be limited by a written grant.…
- 778 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Just like we had our Bill of Rights, there was an English Bill of Rights. Obviously, this listed individual rights like our Bill of Rights. However, this document was written first, passed by parliament on December 16, 1689 to be exact. The English Bill inspired the U.S. Bill which is included in the Constitution. Ideas used in the Constitution include: list of individual rights, right to petition which was include in the Declaration also, bear arms, no cruel or unusual punishment, freedom from taxation, modern day U.S. Bill of rights. The English Bill of Rights also strengthened the Magna Carta.…
- 629 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Magna Carta – (Great Charter) a charter of liberty and political rights obtained from King John of England…
- 3272 Words
- 14 Pages
Good Essays -
The Magna Carta today is more important for what it has become than what it was originally intended. It stands now for government by contract of the people, for fundamental law, for the rule of law, for no taxation without representation, for due process of law, for habeas corpus, for equality before the law, for representative government, and for the rights of the criminally accused.…
- 849 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Although the Magna Carta did not directly lead to human rights or the Declaration of Independence its significance is found in being the the first written laws that challenged the absolute power of a monarch. Clause 39 was one of the few passages that were applied to a commoner and not only an aristocrat. It states that the king could not seize land or arrest someone without a proper cause or a fair trial. Like Gregory explains the Magna Carta mostly, “favored the property interests of rich barons… and not the poor who suffered under a harsh feudal system.”. This is a vital part of Western Tradition because it shows a difference from the other passages where they focused only on the needs of the rich. Clause 39 is different because the people…
- 223 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
Although the original purpose of the charter was to protect the interests of the barons, it was written in such broad terms that future generations could interpret it as a charter of civic liberty, as shown in Article 39, which became the cornerstone for due process.…
- 441 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
7. nnocent Annulling the Magna Carta from The Letters of Pope Innocent III (1198-1216), Concerning England and Wales edited and translated by Christopher R. Cheney and Mary G. Cheney, (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1967), pp. 212-16…
- 2243 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Going in order, I will begin with the Magna Carta (1215). According to the NEH, “the Magna Carta served to lay the foundation for the evolution of parliamentary government and subsequent declarations of rights in Great Britain and the United States.” The Magna Carta defends the “dew process” of the law; everyone has legal rights that the states to follow. “Near the completion of the 13th century, the Magna Carta contributed to the support of the idea of a “higher law,” one that could not be modified by executive mandate or legislative acts,” (NEH, 1996). The notion helped to enfold toward the Supremacy clause of the United States Constitution and enforced by the Supreme Court. This was only the beginning to the making of the Constitution.…
- 869 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Many of the ideas first written in the Magna Carta would later form the basis of modern democracy. It was the first document to limit the powers of the monarchy. This would influence the democratic idea of a system of checks and balances to keep one piece of the government (such as the president) from having too much power. It also established rights for everyday people and influenced the content of other documents that protect the rights of citizens, such as the Bill of Rights in the United States Constitution Another result of the Magna Carta was the establishment of the first English parliament. It created the Great Council, a group of 25 barons that the king was supposed to consult when he made a decision. This planted the seeds of a parliamentary government where the power was shared between the ruling monarch and the people, and the people had a…
- 391 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The Bill of Rights: It was very important measure taken by the parliament which limited the royal power and also established supremacy of the parliament. The bill was passed in February, 1689. It enumerates the act of James II stating that he abdicated from the power by himself. It reduced the power of the king and made the king bound to take into account the consent of the parliament. The king could not suspend or create laws without the allowance of parliament. He could not raise taxes by royal prerogative and he was forbidden to keep standing army in peace.…
- 2107 Words
- 9 Pages
Good Essays