Compare and Contrast Seabiscuit vs Secretariat

Topics: Great Depression, Tobey Maguire, Walt Disney Pages: 2 (759 words) Published: March 22, 2013
Seabiscuit vs. Secretariat

Impossible. A word the average English speaking individual fears. It is defined as: incapable of being done. In 2010 Walt Disney released Secretariat, a movie that tells the impossible true story of possibly, the greatest racehorse ever. Universal Studios DreamWorks released Seabiscuit several years prior. Similarly, the movie Seabiscuit provides its audience with a portal back in time to tell yet another seemingly impossible true story. Except this movie tales the journey of three men and one very special horses’ rise to success and fame. While both films recount inspirational and seemingly impossible true stories, Seabiscuit edges out Secretariat at the wire through the use of a more historically accurate plot, first-class acting and far more believable cinematography. The sheer amount of historical accuracy maintained throughout Seabiscuit far outweighs Walt Disney’s portrayal of Secretariat. In Seabiscuit, each of the main character’s personal struggles is told throughout the first part of the film. These struggles show how the characters came together in real life, provides the audience with an adequate understanding of the effect of the Great Depression on them and allows the viewers to connect emotionally to them as well. In Secretariat, many of the people who were major parts of his journey were completely omitted. The overall feel of the film is very Disney like; in the essence of follow your dreams and they will come true. Ultimately, Walt Disney turned Secretariat into just another dramatic fairy tale. Too many actual events and characters were left out of the film, which in turn, took away from the real drama of Secretariat’s story. Seabiscuit incorporates a narration of the times and also includes historic photos and footage that capture the era. Unlike Secretariat, Seabiscuit manages to not only maintain historical integrity but is quite entertaining as well. Thus making Seabiscuit the clear winner. The first-class...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Essay on Compare Contrast Windows Vs
  • Compare and Contrast Iliad vs. Odessey Essay
  • Compare & Contrast Basketball Vs. Baseball Essay
  • Compare And Contrast Star Wars Vs Essay
  • Essay about Achilles vs Beowulf compare and contrast
  • Compare and Contrast: Women vs Men Essay
  • Compare and Contrast Wendy's vs. Mcdonalds Research Paper
  • Compare and Contrast Texting vs Calling Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free