Cognitive Behavioural Therapy Described as a Sticking Plaster

Only available on StudyMode
  • Download(s) : 239
  • Published : May 25, 2006
Open Document
Text Preview
Cognitive Behavioural Therapy has been described as a ‘sticking plaster' for the problems that people may bring to counselling (Observer, 19/02/06). With reference to the literature, critically evaluate the arguments for and against this view.

Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) is a combination of two kinds of therapy; cognitive therapy and behavioural therapy (Bush, 2005). It has been shown to have a positive impact on a wide range of mood and anxiety disorders, such as depression, insomnia and panic attacks as well as more recently psychosis (schizophrenia).

However, whether or not CBT actually solves the issue at hand or simply covers it up, as a "sticking plaster" (Martin & Helmore, 2006) has recently been a topic of discussion. This has arisen from psychotherapists whom believe that CBT and it's effects are unproven whereas psychotherapy has been around for over a century and worked well for this duration of time, and thus must be better, despite the lack of evidence available. To quote Holmes (2002), "Absence of Evidence is not Evidence of absence". This debate is of high political importance as although psychotherapy has been around for longer, this should not be the leading factor in the debate. People's quality of life is what should be considered and if there is a therapy which will highly improve this then it should seriously be taken into consideration.

CBT does have it's advantages over other forms of therapy. It is a short term project, usually ranging from 8 to 16 sessions. Plus the risks of taking on this style of treatment are low, especially when compared alongside drug therapies which have many side effects. When compared to psychotheraputical methods, CBT is much cheaper and a more short term style of treatment, which certainly has it's advantages. However, as with any relatively new therapy, it's long term effects cannot be fully predicted until it has been in use for many years, although there has been mixed evidence about relapse rates among patients whom have received it (Elkin et al., 1989). Another issue with CBT is it's clinical relevance. Although efficacy is high, it's clinical relevance has been questioned, for instance, Leff, Vearnals Brewin, Wolff, Alexander and Asen (2000) discluded CBT from their trials in treating depression due to it's poor compliance from patients whom were considered as "clinically typical" (Holmes, 2002). Additionally it may show a relatively slow speed of response (Health 24 – News, Sleep, 2004) although research is conflicting and some suggests this not to be true.

One of the current major areas of use for CBT is in the treatment of mood disorders, namely uni-polar depression (depression). Many studies have researched into the efficacy and clinical effectiveness of CBT on patients suffering from depression. Butler, Chapman, Forman and Beck (2006) state that due the large number of psychodynamic therapists available to treat individuals the most important comparisons which need to be made are between these psychodynamic therapies and CBT. One of the largest studies regarding this was carried out by Elkin et al. (1989), comparing the effectiveness of CBT, interpersonal psychotherapy (ITP) and drug therapy. However, no differences were found between the treatments of ITP and CBT and the effects they had upon the depressed patients, although both were found to significantly decrease the depressive symptoms of the subjects. In the more severely depressed patients however, CBT did not fare as well as either ITP or drug therapy, suggesting that it does have limitations in the treatment of depression. Sharpio, Barkham, Rees, Hardy, Reynolds and Startup (1994) used the treatments of CBT and psychodynamic-interpersonal therapy (PIT) in assessing which one was best in the treatment of depression whilst also manipulating the length of treatment. It was found that at the end of the treatment CBT and PIT were equally as effective. However,...
tracking img