Koren Brewer
Professor Lerner
AC502 Regulation
10/17/2014
The city plan did not violate the constitutional taking clause. The plan was aimed at benefiting the public in New London economically by providing jobs to the unemployed and increasing the tax receipts that would ultimately boost the city's public finance and by so doing boost the economy necessary for the city's development.
The takings clause protects the private property from conversion by the state for public use without just compensation. Although the eminent domain gives the state the right to acquire private land for public use, this 5th Amendment provision of the takings clause subjects such conversion to be legitimate, that is be for public use and the compensation be just what is viewed as be fair as per the market value (Turnbull, G. K et al., 2014).
The plan was engineered to boost the low economy by providing jobs to the unemployed and increase the tax receipts that would eventually see the city's economy stabilize. This step is beneficial to the public both directly and indirectly and a legitimate public use of the justly acquired land.
The economic benefits on the other hand appear to be secondary and incidental as brought forth by the dissenting judge. The developers seem to be the primary beneficiary of the acquisition and there is no surety that unemployment will be curbed and hence have the public benefit.
All in all, the entire takings clause is objected towards just compensation of the private land owners where the government acquires such land for public use. From the foregoing the land was put into public use that is faced as economic development having compensated the owners justly. It thus follows that the takings clause was not violated.
Reference
Beatty, J. F., Samuelson, S. S., & Bredeson, D. A. (2013). Introduction to business law. In Introduction to business law (4th, Ch. 11). Mason, OH: South-Western Cengage Learning.
Turnbull, G. K., Salvino Jr, R. F., & Tasto, M. T. (2014). 7. Does the power to use eminent domain for economic development actually enhance economic development?. Entrepreneurial Action, Public Policy, and Economic Outcomes, 119.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
* Hence, if your intention is just 1%, it’s still a profit making scheme! Even if the land was compulsory resumed by the gov.…
- 1307 Words
- 6 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Well, if I was in charge of the project in the city of Ridleyville. I would build a business complex upward to save pace and also build a small size park on the riverfront. However, the reason I choose this decision is because businesses brings other business which will help the economy grow. Also, increase the amount of parkland and open space in the city, especially in the downtown riverfront area. For the city to stay economically sustainable, you need jobs. Also, with the base being close down, that will decrease the job rate in Ridleyville. So the city will have to put something in that area to fill that gap. However, making this decision will help address the growing budget deficit. By building a business complex would lower unemployment rates and increased economic growth reduce the need for government-funded programs such as unemployment insurance and Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF).If the city can get the small portion of open space through tax incentives, they can build a park on the open space.…
- 313 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In the wake of these actions, the city authorized the purchase of property within the development area and to utilize the acquisition of land through eminent domain if need be. Supported by the 14th amendment, the 5th Amendment allows local government the powers to utilize eminent domain to take private property for public use while appropriately compensating the former owners (Supreme Court 2004). During these acquisitions nine party members did not wish to sell their properties and challenged the taking of their land; stating that the transfer of land from one private owner to another to further economic development was a violation of the 5th amendment.…
- 1087 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
In this case, the City of Monroe, North Carolina decided in April of 2002, to supply the citizens of Monroe and surrounding area with natural gas through a direct connection between its natural gas distribution system and the Transcontinental Pipeline. The Transcontinental Pipeline transports and distributes natural gas from the Gulf of Mexico up through the northeastern United States. The parties of this case requested the court to focus on the validity of a local government’s exercise use of its power of eminent domain. According to our textbook, Business Law Text and Cases, eminent domain is sometimes referred to as the condemnation power of government to take land for public use. The town of Monroe, North Carolina entered into an agreement with the town of Midland to facilitate the acquisition of land for the construction of the new pipeline by acquiring the rights of way to local land required for the installation of the pipeline. Per the agreement, Midland had the option to tap the pipeline at discounted rate. Midland then exercised its eminent domain authority to condemn the need…
- 722 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
2. Business owners would probably oppose to this because they thought they've found a great lot to expand their business but then finding out they have a major setback due to complaining residents.…
- 304 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Across most of the world Common Law states that navigable waters are owned by the public at large. Tidelands fall under the category of navigable waters and are therefore protected up to the high high tide line. The protection of public lands has historically fallen on the government and is referred to as the Public Trust Doctrine (PTD). The history of this common law comes from many historical sources including, the Institutes of Justinian in Rome, the Magna Carta in England, and the Siete Partides in Spain (State Lands Commission 2001). The public’s ownership of navigable waters and their protection for the benefit of the public have also been set forth in past court cases and documents issues by numerous state and federal agencies including the State Lands Commission and the Army Corps of Engineers. The responsibility of both the state and local municipalities has been established in past court cases e.g. the Nature Conservancy’s suit regarding Mono Lake diversions. Martin v. Waddell 1842 brought the common law regarding navigable waters to North America. The protection of tidelands was entrusted to the original 13 colonies. The Equal Footing Doctrine that resulted from Pollard’s Lesee v. Hagan 1845 gave all states the responsibility to protect the public’s interest in navigable waters i.e. tidelands. Consequently the California State Legislature was entrusted with protecting the tidelands of California at its inception in 1850. The California State Legislature’s sale of the tidelands from 1858 to 1872 runs contrary to the Public Trust Doctrine. The legislature’s recognition that selling the tidelands was an egregious violation of the PTD can be inferred from the amendments to the state constitution in 1879 and 1910 that expressly protected the public’s right to access and fish the waterways (Article 1 section 25, Article X section 4). None the less abuse of the PTD has resulted in a mass…
- 3273 Words
- 14 Pages
Best Essays -
Families “owned” the right to use of land, but they did not own the land itself…
- 1321 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Like many IT staff faced with exponential storage growth, Norman Owens realized a few years back that his company was headed for a challenge if it did not start consolidating its storage resources onto a storage area network (SAN). Owens, a storage network engineer and consultant with Carlson Companies, spoke to an audience of his peers at Storage Decisions 2003 recently about his company 's consolidation efforts. (While not necessarily a household name, Carlson Companies is an international presence behind such well-known retail and hotel chains as TGI Friday 's and Radisson hotels and resorts. Before consolidating onto a SAN, Owens ' shared services group supported a configuration with one mainframe and 26 servers, where most of the servers were hard at work supporting the company 's Oracle Financials database under HP/UX. This arrangement handled 14TB of data, over 54 SCSI and 8 ESCON connections. "It looked like a point-to-point SCSI solution," Owens said, noting, "There were a whole lot of cables." When they needed more storage, "We 'd just go buy another frame. After the company asked his group to take on more responsibilities for its global IT storage operations, Owens and his coworkers decided now was the time to look at a more consolidated approach. Enter the company 's current storage over IP "fan-out" infrastructure, with Nishan Systems ' switches and a core/edge design that Owens affectionately calls "the funnel." Commenting on their decision to move into IP-based solutions, Owens said that the ability to connect remote sites was something "we had to do, or else our storage wouldn 't have been approved." The company rolled out its extensive SAN consolidation in phases. Today, it consists of 108…
- 1474 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The basic underlying philosophy for the doctrine of adverse possession is that historically land use has been favoured over disuse. The doctrine protects ownership by barring stale claims of non-occupiers and errors in the title records. The intention is not to "reward the diligent trespasser for his wrong nor to penalise the negligent and dormant owner for sleeping upon his rights..." .…
- 1447 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
“Advantages associated with proposed changes and intensification of Land Use include greater short-term economic productivity, improved jobs/housing ratio, increased employment base and increased tax and related revenues for the area. Increases in revenue and community convenience generated as a result of implementation of the Draft Framework Plan will, however, be offset by the expenditures necessary to provide the supporting services and related resources to selected infrastructure improvements that, once built and financed, would serve the area. Disadvantages normally associated with this short-term productivity include:…
- 739 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Per the article The Rights of the British Colonies Asserted and Proved, “The supreme court power cannot take from any man any part of his property, without his consent in person or by representation.” This law is stating that the government cannot take any man’s property from him. Also, the…
- 618 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Clear property rights must be characterized by the bundle of rights allowed to owner of the property-use rights, right to exchange etc.; or by benefit of exclusion- one person’s property right excludes all others in ownership and sharing of benefits arising out of ownership. Keeping this in mind we will attempt to answer two questions- i) What is the basis of eminent domain in terms of property rights and ii) how important are private property rights to the proper implementation of eminent…
- 1001 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
These include needs for safety and security. Security needs are important for survival, but they are not as demanding as the physiological needs. Examples of security needs include a desire for steady employment, health care, safe neighborhoods, and shelter from the environment.…
- 956 Words
- 3 Pages
Powerful Essays -
1. That the plaintiff is a reputed businessman lives in house no B24 Mirpur 10 Dhaka..…
- 3270 Words
- 14 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
This will activate other industries in our country that will result in job creation and lessening new entrants and “part-timers” in real estate.…
- 507 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays