Case Study

Topics: Immanuel Kant, Categorical imperative, Ethics Pages: 3 (578 words) Published: March 11, 2013
Albor,Emilio Gabriel P. March 12, 2013
MAS-3 MAS70 – B2
Case Study No. 2: Working for Eli Lily and Company
Analyze and discuss the case using:
A. Utilitarianism
SOCIETAL BENEFITS| SOCIETAL COSTS|
* Less crime in the streets * Can cure disease * Job offer * Offered shelter * Number of alcoholic people will decrease * Number of homeless people decrease. * Increase of motel customers * New medicine * Cleanliness in the streets * Less annoyance in the streets * Increased succession rate of drug researching * Can help find missing persons * Safer in the streets * More secure| * Increase of death toll * Faster productivity of drug research * New medicine or drugs * More will be injured * Increased number of the ill * More contagious disease * Inhuman practice|

Therefore, it can consequently bring to a close that continuing on getting human test subject or homeless alcoholics is morally acceptable since the societal benefits outweigh the societal costs. B. Rights

Homeless Alcoholic
* The right to choose
* The right to live
* The right to work
* The right to be safe
* The right to have fun

C. Kant’s Categorical Imperatives
* Categorical Imperative 1: Morally wrong, because not all people are aware or have agreed to be a human research or test subject. Though many homeless alcoholic chose to be one, there are still some who chose to be not. * Categorical Imperative 2: Morally wrong, simply because the homeless alcoholics are used as guinea pigs or tools for the success of the research.

D. Justice and Fairness
Distributive Justice
Benefits
* The benefit is that eli lily will not pay almost $250/day for the test subjects. * Eli Lily won’t have problems with getting test subject to volunteer. * Provides the test subjects easy money

Burden
* The burden Is for the test subjects that has felt the side effects of the...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • case study Essay
  • case study Essay
  • Case Study Essay
  • CASE STUDY Essay
  • Case Study Research Paper
  • Case Study Essay
  • case study Essay
  • CASE STUDIES Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free