Case Analysis Evaluation Criteria
FOX MBA: MIS5301/MIS5401 CASE ANALYSIS RUBRIC
TRAIT
1 - Limited
2 - Developing
3 - Proficient
4 - Exemplary
Comprehensively and clearly identifies and describes the issue/opportunity including all key components/variables and relevant information. Displays full understanding of issue.
Presents an insightful and thorough analysis of all questions. Supports analysis with logical arguments and evidence; presents balanced view drawn from multiple sources of knowledge. Presents well-reasoned, and insightful recommendations/ decisions supported by comprehensive and reliable evidence and/or data. Little or no omission evidence. Anticipates/identifies most of the current as well as future implications and consequences of the recommendations/decisions Little or no omissions in the identification of implications and consequences.
BR1
Issue/Problem
Identification
(15%)
Limited ability to clearly identify the issue/opportunity and its various components/variables.
Correctly identifies issue/opportunity but certain key components/variables remain unclear or omitted.
Precisely identifies and describes the issue/opportunity including the majority of its key components/variables.
Understanding of issue is not impeded by the omission of undefined variables.
ANA
Analysis and
Application
(20%)
Strategic
Recommendations
& Decisions
(20%)
BR5
Implications
& Consequences
(15%)
Presents a superficial analysis of some of the questions. Supports analysis with limited reasons and evidence; presents a somewhat one-sided argument with little integration of material beyond the case. Presents some complete, clear, and realistic recommendations/ decisions supported by some complete and reliable evidence and/or data.
Omissions of evidence may impact credibility. Identifies some current implications and consequences of recommendations/decisions and displays ability to anticipate/identify some future implications accurately.
Omissions may impact success of
recommendations/decisions.
TRAIT
1 - Limited
2 - Developing
3 - Proficient
4 - Exemplary
Comprehensively and clearly identifies and describes the issue/opportunity including all key components/variables and relevant information. Displays full understanding of issue.
Presents an insightful and thorough analysis of all questions. Supports analysis with logical arguments and evidence; presents balanced view drawn from multiple sources of knowledge. Presents well-reasoned, and insightful recommendations/ decisions supported by comprehensive and reliable evidence and/or data. Little or no omission evidence. Anticipates/identifies most of the current as well as future implications and consequences of the recommendations/decisions Little or no omissions in the identification of implications and consequences.
BR1
Issue/Problem
Identification
(15%)
Limited ability to clearly identify the issue/opportunity and its various components/variables.
Correctly identifies issue/opportunity but certain key components/variables remain unclear or omitted.
Precisely identifies and describes the issue/opportunity including the majority of its key components/variables.
Understanding of issue is not impeded by the omission of undefined variables.
ANA
Analysis and
Application
(20%)
Strategic
Recommendations
& Decisions
(20%)
BR5
Implications
& Consequences
(15%)
Presents a superficial analysis of some of the questions. Supports analysis with limited reasons and evidence; presents a somewhat one-sided argument with little integration of material beyond the case. Presents some complete, clear, and realistic recommendations/ decisions supported by some complete and reliable evidence and/or data.
Omissions of evidence may impact credibility. Identifies some current implications and consequences of recommendations/decisions and displays ability to anticipate/identify some future implications accurately.
Omissions may impact success of
recommendations/decisions.
References: (10%) 1 (F) 2 (C) 3 (B) 4 (A)