There are a number of advantages to using referendums as a way to make big decisions. The biggest reason is the fact that direct democracy is the fairest and purest way of making decisions as it is entirely up to the people to decide. Whilst you would not regularly use referendums to deal with every issue that parliament would have to deal with, they are a very good way of dealing with a single, important issue. Referendums are also good for the electorate. Many people believe that voting in general elections is pointless, largely because they believe that their vote doesn’t really count in the grand scheme of things, especially if you live in an area where your party is always voted in second. However with referendums, every vote counts, and the electorate recognise this and as a result turn out in massive numbers. This also strengthens the support of the political system in the people. It encourages people to become better educated in politics, whilst providing politicians with an insight into the electorate’s opinions.
However there are also a large amount of disadvantages when it comes to referendums. The most obvious is that it blatantly undermines the representative democracy system used in this country, which generally works quite well. Many of the disadvantages with regards to referendums are evident in the current Scottish independence referendum. For example, if the result is close, countries will often feel divided over the issue. This is the case in Scotland, where the polls indicate that the result is going to be very close, and there are definite tensions on the streets between the supporters of the two campaigns, with many no voters saying that they get abuse in the street if they publically show their choice. There are problems with letting the public make such large decisions, as they will often be the wrong ones. People in this country tend to have ignorance towards politics, and so when these people are allowed to make such big decisions, they will often vote using their emotions, rather than choosing what is best.
Ethan Mulvey
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
This could possibly lead to the population being more engaged in politics. The citizens will be more encouraged to learn about what is happening in politics and attending turnouts. The voices of unheard citizens will now have a voice. Acta Politica once said that, “compulsory voting sends the message that every vote matters, it is able to restore rather than harm democracy and its values”. All equivalent interest in the system is helping to be ensured by mandatory…
- 602 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Referendums are likely to give additional power to pressure groups and other organisations that would seek to influence the outcome. Take the Scottish referendum held two weeks ago. The die hard Scott’s were hugely influencing the rest of the population to vote for independence by using anti-UK propaganda. However if they went independent then Scotland would of faced a gloomy downward spiral. The ‘Yes’ campaigners were voting for an independent Scotland, which was uncertain which currency it was going to use, which had no…
- 1040 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Referendums cause the public to become more educated and engaged, which would help the UK to become more democratic. For example, the Scottish referendum scheduled to take place next year has already started campaigning, with their “Yes, Scotland” campaign. Through activities like campaigning, the government can engage the public and they then become more educated about it.…
- 941 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Secondly, First Past The Post has had a big impact on UK democracy. The system we use to elect our MPs has a real impact on how politics works in Britain. It has a direct effect on whether politicians truly represent us and whether we can hold them to account if they let us down. The defeat of the 2011 Alternative Vote (AV) referendum means it is now more important than ever to discredit our failed system and we are continuing to build the case for change at Westminster. This in turn means any of our votes just don’t count. Millions of people have no chance of deciding who their MP will be. And our votes are wasted by the system. Additionally, parties continue to focus all their time, money and effort on a handful of 'marginal seats', so just a few thousand voters can decide who runs Britain.…
- 752 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The 1967 referendum is about including Aboriginals people in the census and allowing the commonwealth to make laws for the aboriginals. At the same time of the referendum, harold Holt was the prime minister and liberal was in power. Before the referendum, there was a question in the census to establish the number of full blood aborigines society viewed aboriginals as a disadvantage. Aboriginal were able to vote in 1962, however they have no potential power and although they are allowed to vote, they are not counted in the census. Australia became more aware of the discrimination and of what other countries think of them and they finally removed the discrimination from federal legislation. At this time, the laws regarding the aboriginal is the responsibility of the states government. Consequently, if an aboriginal moved to another state, their rights might be gained or lost. Furthermore by the end of 1966, aboriginal people has been granted legal rights but not citizenship. A boriginals tried to be counted as Australians and a referendum was done to change the australian convention. A referendum is a voting system, where people vote yes or no to something and a majority of vote will win. Therefore the federal council campaign for a yes vote in the referendumThe context of the referendum is quite good. The aboriginals were hopeful towards the referendum and has faith on getting counted in the census because they successfully gaines the rights to vote in previous times. They believe that their chances of winning this referendum is strong. In addition, the Government also…
- 736 Words
- 2 Pages
Better Essays -
Referendums could improve democracy in many ways, for example, it could help the votes and policies be more precise, because people are individually voting on specific policies, which therefore make the UK more democratic as it would be more representative towards minority groups in society. The referendums could also promote political education of the voters, as it can bring issues to attention by using the media, which would make the voters more aware of the…
- 671 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
However there are both many advantages and disadvantages of using this electoral system. Firstly it delivers proportional outcomes and it also ensures that votes are largely of equal values. In addition, the threshold is…
- 2195 Words
- 9 Pages
Good Essays -
Referendums make government more responsive by forcing them to listen to the public opinion between elections. Moreover, they allow public opinion to be expressed on a particular issue, something that is difficult to achieve via elections and impossible to achieve if all parties agree on an issue.…
- 500 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The first way in which the UK democracy participation can be strengthened is increasing the use of referendums. A referendum is asking a political question to those eligible to vote e.g. the AV (alternative vote) referendum in 2010. An advantage of an increased use in referendums would be that it’s a more direct form of speaking to the public from the governments’ point of view and therefore allows the public to make a decision on an important government matter; this will help the public gain trust in the politicians again as the public feel like they’re decision making. However a disadvantage of an increased use of referendums would be that they are very expensive to carry out and considering that only 42% of eligible voters actually voted in the 2010 AV referendum it would seem to be a waste of money and time if no one will participate.…
- 754 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Johnson once said “Peace is a journey of a thousand miles and it must be taken one step at a time”. Johnson was a president who had his own priorities and the priorities of others in his mind at all times. The war for civil rights was at its peak and before the election Johnson was noticeably against civil rights until one day he changed his mind. What forced Johnson to change his mind about civil rights, and why did he sign the civil rights act of 1964? Did Johnson have any personal motives for signing it, or did he do it for the people?…
- 509 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Another reason why referendums are held in the UK is constitutional change and being able to make the change legitimate. An example of this is the 1998 referendum in London. The question asked was ‘Are you in favour of the government’s proposals for a Greater London Authority made up of an elected major and a separately elected assembly? A referendum was needed so the government can get the consent of the people to bring a major and consent to imply taxation increase that would be needed to introduce a major an elected assembly. This would not just affect the way the people are being represented by having a major to help introduce change and important matters concluded but also increase the amount of tax people are paying the be able to fund the Major and the elected assembly that were being introduced as well.…
- 603 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Pros- The electoral College allows each states vote to count, instead of focusing only on states with larger populations.…
- 447 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The Australian Referendum of 1967, called by Prime Minister Harold Holt, led to important and influential decisions and legislations; which ultimately bettered the lives of the first Australians. Although the amendments made to the constitution, were minimal and overall didn't immediately amount to much, it was significant in the progression of the mentality of Australian society. One of the most obvious reasons as to why the referendum still resonates with the people today is that it was the first example of national support for Indigenous Australians. It was also the first time Indigenous Australians were counted, in accordance with state…
- 927 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Another reason why the first past the post system suits Britain is that it is a simple and easily understood system. Compared to systems like the alternative vote and additional member system it is far less complex. This encourages turnout as it is simply ticking a box. This encourages those who find politics and the systems surrounding it confusing to vote. Not only is it important to receive everybody’s vote but everyone is confident and sure they have voted correctly.…
- 1268 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
“Den dey all laughed real hard. But before Ah seen de picture Ah thought Ah wuz just like de rest.” (Hurston 9)…
- 279 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays