Preview

Biomedical Ethics Case Study: Scott Starson's Refusal of Treatment while Being Incompetent

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1143 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Biomedical Ethics Case Study: Scott Starson's Refusal of Treatment while Being Incompetent
Scott Starson: Refusing treatment while Incompetent…

Date Submitted: Monday, November 23rd 2014
Course: Biomedical Ethics (online class)

Scott Starson, a brilliant physicist has been in and out of mental institutions due to his bipolar disorder. He was lastly admitted again after he made death threats to his roommates and was found not criminally responsible for that offense. His physicians suggested different sorts of treatment for his illness. Scott Starson refused to give consent to the treatment for reason that he had a scientific research to finish and he didn’t want the medications to slow him down. His physicians not finding him competent enough to critically make that kind of decision, brought the case before a medical review board, which afterwards also confirmed that Mr Starson was not competent enough to decide whether to reject or accept the treatment. Mr Starson unhappy with the decision, applied for a review to the Ontario consent and capacity board (CcB) –The CcB’s mission is to fairly review/judge the different consent and capacity issues while balancing both the rights of vulnerable individuals1– In this case they had to review if Mr. Starson had the required capacity to accept or refuse treatment based on the health care consent act.
After studying the case, the Ccb also agreed with the physicians that Starson was not capable to appreciate the outcome of the administered treatment and their decision was based on the following consent: “ The Ontario Health Care Consent Act permitted a person to be treated without consent on the ground of lack of capacity (the ability to make an informed choice), if it was found that they could not understand the information relevant to making a decision about treatment and could not appreciate the reasonable foreseeable consequences of that decision.” 2 The case was finally appealed to the supreme court of Canada for a conclusive decision. The court agreed with the act/law that guided



Bibliography:

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Healthcare Law and Ethics

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages

    My paper is on patient dumping which happens when a medical treatment facility may treat a patient initally for acute symptoms but then realizes the patient has no means to pay for the medical services rendered. In some cases back in the 1990 's it was found that a patient was put into a cab and the cab driver paid to take the patient away and let out on a street corner somewhere in a city in the USA. Some stories have been told that patients only had on a hospital gown and diaper and dumped on the curb. Usually these patients are older population, may have dementia or are chronic alcoholics and are too sick to care for themselves. Of course this practice is illegal after Congress passed the “Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act (EMTALA), sometimes referred to as COBRA since it was part of the year’s Consolidated Omnibus Budget”. (http://www.nurseweek.com, Karen Markus, JD, RN, p 1.)…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Brewster v. University Hospital is a case that deals with informed consent, in this case the plaintiff seemed to be wronged in the sense that their child was not given the best opportunity for a full recovery. The defendant, however, believes no wrong has been done since the professionals are certain that the diagnosis was best for the patient. The argument develops in the sense that the parents of the patient were not informed of all the different diagnosis, and how this illness could affect their child’s brain development. The patient suffered from hyperbilirubinemia, or jaundice, which seems to be of a normal occurrence for many infants, but it must be controlled because high levels of bilirubin causes great damage to the brain. This was part of the information the Brewster’s were not informed of, along with the fact that there is a much more aggressive form of diagnosis for this illness, which is blood…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A common and controversial issue facing many medical professionals is medical paternalism versus patient autonomy. At the heart of every practitioner/patient relationship is trust, and the duty to uphold the patient’s best interest both ethically and privately. These foundations seem basic on the surface, but underneath lies a much more complex issue. Medical paternalism can be defined as the intervening of a person’s decision making or actions for her own good.1 Oftentimes, medical paternalism can be considered as interfering with the patient’s autonomy and right to make an intentional, uninfluenced decision regarding her own medical care. Such interference can come in the form of decisions regarding the patient’s physical or psychological care. However, there must be certain caveats in which medical paternalism is unavoidable, and therefore acceptable as an act done in the patient’s best interest, while still holding true to the clinician’s obligation to the patient. This type of paternalism is referred to as weak paternalism.2…

    • 1377 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    related to the use of various information technologies that gather and store data and perform…

    • 2077 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Although Gibson (2001) argues that knowledge alone does not change health outcomes for patients, to allow Jo to give informed consent she would need information that was relevant to her condition and treatment. Jo is an intelligent women and giving her a choice of treatment would have protected her autonomy (Edwards 1996) and individual rights (Caress 2003), however Jo was not offered a choice in treatment, and alternatives were not discussed. The district nurse made a decision and applied the treatment. In doing this the district nurse used his power to manipulate Jo into accepting the treatment the he wanted to give. Giving restricted information the nurse restricted the patient 's choices to secure her compliance (Lukes 1974). The district nurses actions went against advocating the government Expert Patient Policy (DOH 2000), which highlights the need for changes in society that mean individuals expect to have choices, and be involved in decision making (Kenney 2003). Although Jo gave consent for the treatment given, she…

    • 5165 Words
    • 21 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    When we think of hospital staff, we often think of physicians, nurses, or other caregivers. These caregivers are only a part of the staff required to manage an efficient hospital. Behind the scenes there is hidden, incredibly important role in health services delivery - healthcare executive administration. Healthcare executives are responsible for providing the most basic of social services, the care of dependent people at one of the most vulnerable times in their lives. The goal of a healthcare executive is to make a positive difference in the lives of people and communities.…

    • 887 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tabet Vs Gett Case Study

    • 1533 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The case concerned an appeal of a medical negligence case regarding a child who was misdiagnosed until a CT scan revealed that she, in fact, had a brain tumour . The treating physician was then subsequently sued on the basis that since the physician had not performed the CT scan when the child had been misdiagnosed . Therefore the child had lost the chance to have the brain tumour treated before the sustaining of permanent brain damage . At first instance, the case succeeded but failed on appeal . Additionally, the High Court also rejected the claim, on the basis that there were no policy reasons that would allow for recovery of damages based on a less than even chance of a better medical outcome . In spite of this, the High Court did not eliminate the possibility that a claim in a future medical case above the purported 50% standard would be allowed . Meanwhile, the case of Tabet v Gett (2010) demonstrates that patients that suffer as a result of medical negligence in Australia will face large injustice issues specifically in cases of late diagnosis. Therefore, it is only fitting to highlight the High Court’s stance on commercial chances where the High Court rejected the appellant’s argument that the fact that Australia already recognises loss of chance in commercial cases means that loss…

    • 1533 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Healthcare professionals face the challenge of resolving ethical dilemmas on a regular basis. This paper will discuss a hypothetical ethical dilemma in a healthcare setting as if it were the author’s. Competing loyalties between the organization and patient will be indentified and an ethical response will be provided along with contrasting ethical responses. Implications to risk management will be considered and an ethical decision making model will be identified to guide future actions.…

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Furthermore, the fact that someone with mental illness has been assessed and found lacking capacity or confused because of their medication does not necessarily mean that they cannot choose or make decisions. The service user’s way of thinking may be affected by the medication, but they will be able to make simple decisions. For example, they may choose whether to take sugar in their tea or not to and they may recognise which medication tastes bitter and want to avoid it. In Simon’s case, it seems that the healthcare professionals do not obtain consent any more because of his mental illness and age, which leads them to forget his rights by assuming the role of acting in his best interest. The healthcare professionals claim that they will be…

    • 361 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    There are many issues that trouble the health care industry. The technological revolution that has been taking place the last 20 years has not only taken the healthcare industry by storm, and revolutionized it, but it also has made it take a closer look at its privacy laws. “Patient’s rights are those basic rule of conduct between patient and medical care givers as well as institutions and people that support them” (Davis 2013).Being able to provide patient confidentiality is essential and crucial in establishing a long lasting relationship with patients. In this essay I will explain the importance of that bond and what happens when that…

    • 1091 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Post by Day 3 your analysis and assessment of the ethical and economic challenges related to policy decisions such as those presented in the Washington Post article. How does this type of situation contribute to the tension between cost and care? Substantiate your response with at least two outside resources.…

    • 878 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The following is an excerpt from the book Clinical Ethics: A Practical Approach to Ethical Decisions in Clinical Medicine, 4th Edition. Copyright permission to reproduce this excerpt has been generously granted by McGraw-Hill. We encourage you to read further in this useful resource book, available now in the revised 7th Edition (2010). . Albert R. Jonsen, Mark Siegler, and William J. Winslade, Clinical Ethics: A Practical Approach to Ethical Decisions in Clinical Medicine, 4th edition. New York: McGraw-Hill, Inc., .…

    • 3899 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    This is a very complex scenario. To prevent patient not be a victim from others, the healthcare organization must have some sort of policies and guidelines in place to protect the patient and privacy and confidentiality. According to Westrick (2014), the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 has expanded patients’ rights to confidentiality concerning protected health information held by any healthcare organization which includes physician, insurance companies, and or any entities. As we look at the actions of these doctors and the husband, they are unethical. If these doctors act according to the request of the patient’s husband, this action will compromise the patient right which may be considered as a violation. The role of a medical professional is to be the advocate to those who are in needs, to treat the patient according to their needs, and to protect but not to arm. All the medical professional should take into account the inherent rights of patients. Upon the school graduation, the doctors have taken the Hippocratic Oath in respecting the patient’s privacy and be the patient’s advocate. “The practice of…

    • 396 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ethical considerations can be quite subjective as they are not consolidated through legislations. This can be defined more as a moral duty that paramedics must follow according to Blaber et al. (2012). Due to the demands of the job and having to make quick clinical decision, ethical consideration are sometimes put aside. This is why Beauchamp and Childress (2001) have created a list of four principles to approach ethics to help paramedics be better clinicians.…

    • 395 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Health Care

    • 844 Words
    • 4 Pages

    References: Fremgen, B.F. (2009). Medical Law and Ethics( 3rd ed.) Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Prentice Hall…

    • 844 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays