Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Beowulf v. Star Wars Compare & Contrast

Good Essays
686 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Beowulf v. Star Wars Compare & Contrast
The idea of the monomyth can be mentioned in classic literature as well as in mono motion pictures. The definition Joseph Campbell gives of a hero deals with eight stages. These eight stages can be found in Beowulf in addition to Star Wars. Beowulf, the strongest of the people known as Geats, proclaimed that he would help get rid of the monster that was terrorizing the Danes. Star Wars', Luke Skywalker was a simple farm boy and became the greatest hero the galaxy had ever known. Luke was born during the chaos as the galaxy transitioned from Republic to the tyrannical Empire. Beowulf and Luke both had a boon, a timely blessing or benefit, from which they were given. The goal of the two heroes was to save their part of the world. Though they saved their part of the world successfully, they too reached a nadir. Although Beowulf and Star Wars are dissimilar stories, both hold many similarities.

Even so, one cannot ignore the differences from the two stories. For instance, the technology used in Star Wars, was by far, more advanced compared to the basic technology in which Beowulf used. More so, a mental force guided Luke whereas Beowulf believed it was the help of God. It was rather clear that Luke was a young man compared to Beowulf being elder. Lastly, Beowulf had the advantage to defeat all of his enemies yet ended up dying whereas Luke had the benefit of living.

Notwithstanding the differences, the two stories are clearly similar. For example, it is relevant that when being a hero, a boon will always be present. In this case, the boon for Luke was the gift of power. Luke was always told that the Force was with him. Beowulf's boon was fame from fighting and defeating the unconquerable monsters. Each of the hero's goals was to save their part of the world. Both achieved that goal when defeating the wrongdoers. Luke defeated his enemy, Darth Vader and his men, as well as saving Princess Leia. Beowulf fought and killed anyone who tried to hurt the people of Geatland and the Danes. His name was held with great honor after his death.

Though the two can be referred to as "heroes," they too reached a nadir, or lowest point. Luke's nadir was when he and Princess Leia came out of the Death Star. The Death Star was the code name of an unspeakably powerful and horrific weapon developed by the Empire. The immense space station carried a weapon capable of destroying entire planets. The Death Star was to be an instrument of terror, meant to cow treasonous worlds with the threat of annihilation. As Luke and Princess Leia stood outside the Death Star, they observed as Obi-Wan Kenobi died. Beowulf's nadir came as he went to fight Grendel's mother in the swampy lake. As his people awaited his return, there was no sign of him. Beowulf's people began to think he died and gave up, leaving him behind as they walked off.

The concept of a monomyth can be pointed out in both mono motion pictures as well as classic literature. Joseph Campbell's description of a hero can be established in Beowulf as well as Star Wars. In his book, The Power of Myth, Campbell found eight traits that are common to heroes in mythology from all different cultures. Though Beowulf and Luke were dissimilar stories, they held similarities as well. Both heroes consisted of a boon, saving their part of the world, and reached a nadir. The boon that Luke had was the gift of power. He would always have the force with him. Beowulf's fame became his boon from defeating all the monsters. Luke saved his part of the world by defeating Darth Vader and his men as well as saving Princess Leia. As for Beowulf, allowing Geatland and the Danes to live a much more comfortable life occurred when he killed all of the monsters, which saved his part of the world. Luke's nadir occurred when Obi-Wan Kenobi died and as for Beowulf, his appeared when his people let him down thinking he died.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Firstly, both stories’ main protagonists represent the positive expectations of good individuals in their respective societies. In turn, the monsters and antagonists of the stories represent the marginalities of Anglo-Saxon society and the lowly peasants of English society. Lastly, both books explore similar themes of greed and wrath through the characterization of a dragon, and Tolkien builds upon social commentary present in Beowulf to create a statement about the social illnesses that lead to the Great Depression. At first glance, these works of art seem vastly different and unconnected. However, careful observation reveals that pieces of prose and poetry written throughout history have a tendency to repeat literary themes, borrowing from one another and morphing ideas to create more relevant and more compelling…

    • 1201 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    The first and foremost difference I can think of is the fact the Link has an emotional and character-building journey alongside his physical one. Over the course of the story he changes from a simple farm hand to the kingdom’s greatest hero, having overcome loss, grief, and a plethora of hard puzzles. Unlike Link, Beowulf’s character arc remains seemingly static during the course of his story, save for how he changed from a young prince to an old king. Personality-wise, Beowulf is also rather stagnant. He comes off as cocky and prideful, the text even stating, “But I will fight again, seek fame still,” which implies that a lot of his great works were performed for fame and attention. Meanwhile, Link has a humble and kind personality, and is well loved by those he knows. Even a mischief-making princess from another dimension became his greatest ally due to his kindness towards her. He’s not boastful about his efforts, but instead goes about them in a dutiful manner, risking it all to bring his kingdom back to…

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Beowulf and Hercules

    • 308 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Beowulf and Hercules are both extremely heroic characters with tons of characteristics that make them that seem that way. Both Hercules and Beowulf are very well known heroes that have had stories told about them for hundreds and hundreds of years. They both have similarities and differences but the similarities definitely outweigh the differences.…

    • 308 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    A literary symbol is something often an object that stands for a significant concept or series of ideas often a symbol is emblematic of the values of the characters. In the narrative Beowulf and the movie Star Wars, many aspects of symbolism are paralleled. In the movie Star Wars the most important examples are the Death Star, light sabers and the force. In Beowulf, some of the most important examples of symbolism are Grendel's arm and head, the dragon's treasure-trove Hrothgar's mead-hall and Grendel's cave.…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    At the end of both stories Beowulf and Maximus dies. They both fought for their people. Beowulf fought to save King Hrothgar and his men, while Maximus fault for Rome. It was Beowulf's destiny to make sure that his people were safe, and it was Maximus destiny to free the slaves. They were both destined to go to heaven.…

    • 369 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Religion In Beowulf

    • 1427 Words
    • 6 Pages

    It has some differences, but then some things in common as well. Religion is a part of the poem, movie, and as well real life. Beowulf is one of the types that doesn't care about faith or anything having to deal with Christianity. He thinks that he is fine the way he is and thinks that baptism won't give him protection. Beowulf is the opposite of the characters and is not going to deal with religion. Unlike other characters who have their faith and believe in God. Culture makes a huge impact on a person’s belief and makes them who they are. We see how it's like for Beowulf and Wrathgar in the movie. They both have different thoughts, feeling, and opinions about religion and other as well. Along with an addition to the characters in the movie it kind of shows the different cultures of each person and as well if they are Christians or not. It emphasizes their beliefs about things that happen. Culture is very important in the way a person thinks and believes in their…

    • 1427 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Beowulf and Achilles have many similarities but also have their differences. Achilles defeated out of his anger, but Beowulf defeated for his nation. Although, they are both courageous epic heroes. They were not afraid to face death to defeat their enemy. They have different personalities and come from a complete different culture, but they will also hold the same similarity of being a hero for their…

    • 464 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Grendel Vs Beowulf

    • 1279 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Throughout the film, it isn't hard to notice that Beowulf is more noble and slightly a more gentlemen. It shows him fighting to protect the people of the kingdom; he doesn't just do this for the fame, glory, or rewards. That is what we did know of Beowulf in the book though. His fighting was just to be self-centered and selfishly misusing his abilities for his own good, not for the good of others. Both Beowulf vs. Beowulf have completely different personalities in the film and book, and do each task in a different way. All that was just discussed of Beowulf was all regard to the concept of honor, good and evil.…

    • 1279 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    From epic battles to dodging women, Beowulf and Sir Gawain are classic stories that many people enjoy. Both stories are about men and their quests with their own intentions. One with the intent to help a family friend and the other for the sake of adventures and games. While both men have different personalities and character development, they are similar in their nobility, intelligence, and social status.…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The first major similarity between these battles is that Beowulf for the most part he fights alone. During the first battle Beowulf fights against not only Grendal, but also against his men which shows how good of a fighter Beowulf because he was able to defeat them even though he was outnumbered. In his second battle, when fighting against Grendal’s mother he goes down to the bottom of the lake without his men to battle against her. During the third battle, his men desert him during the intense fight so Beowulf is left alone to fight his most challenging battle yet. In the end Beowulf is unable to defeat the dragon so he was left to lose alone.…

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the differences between the two books is that the protagonists, Beowulf and Sydney Carton, are more comparable than most people would think. In Beowulf the main character is obviously Beowulf and he is a strong and resilient character that fights to help those who need it. In Beowulf it says he was, “greater and stronger than anyone anywhere in this world….” (lines 109-111). Beowulf has to kill Grendel to save the people of Denmark and lose many of his own men along the way. He does eventually kill Grendel and then Grendel’s Mother to save the people. “But Beowulf longed only for fame, leaped back into battle” (lines 502-504) this shows Beowulf’s heart to finish what he started. He never gave up no matter how difficult it was to continue after his men were killed or no matter how hard it was to fight the monsters. Sydney Carton on the other hand first appears as a lazy, alcoholic attorney who cannot muster even the smallest amount of interest in his own life. He describes his existence as a supreme waste of life and takes every opportunity to declare that he cares for nothing and no one. Carton by the end of story changes immensely and becomes a better man. Now Carton isn’t strong resilient like Beowulf but he is…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Even though the tales have major similarities, they also have key dissimilarities as well. The main character is an obvious difference of the two. In Beowulf, the main character is a heroic Viking warrior, but in The 13th Warrior, the main character is an educated Muslim poet who is chosen to travel with Beowulf and the other warriors. Another difference is the order in which the battles take place. For example, in the 13th warrior, killing of the Wendol takes place after the killing of its mother, but in Beowulf, Grendel is killed before the mother. The last key difference between the two is that, the main character dies toward the end in Beowulf, but in The 13th Warrior, the main character does not die.…

    • 488 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Beowolf Book vs Movie

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages

    First off in the book when Beowulf encounters Grendel's mother he kills her by cutting her head off with a magical sword. In the story Beowulf has a cousin named Wiglaf we don't get to know about him until later in the story. Wiglaf also kills the dragon when Beowulf is too weak to fight. We also don't get to know that much of what Wiglaf looks like. In the story Beowulf does become king but it's of his homeland called Geet Land and not of the Danes. In the story The Grendel is a decedent of the Cain’s, which means hell in Old English. In "Beowulf" the story Beowulf also fights sea monsters with a giant sword when he goes to fight The Grendel's Mother. Lastly all the characters in "Beowulf" the story are flat characters meaning that they are not so much human and don't change feelings a lot.…

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jesus V. Beowufl

    • 491 Words
    • 2 Pages

    One could argue that the two are not comparable because they aren't in the same category, being that Beowulf is the basis of an epic poem, and Jesus is the basis of an entire faith. However, if you look at the two in a scientific standpoint, and ignore any personal bias you may or may not have because of religion, you'll see that the two are very similar. While Beowulf claimed that there was no man stronger than he, Jesus said "He that is not with me is against me, and he that gathereth not with me scattereth abroad..." (Matthew 12:30). So both have an attitude of superiority. Beowulf was the king of the Geats, and Jesus was the king of the Jews. Beowulf saved the Danish from Grendel and his mother, while Jesus cleared the sin of all mankind. Beowulf had an awesome sword, and tremendous amounts of strength, Jesus can change water into wine, and cure incurable diseases.…

    • 491 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gender Roles In Beowulf

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the movie and the poem beowulf likes to boast a lot to tell stories about to make him sound like a Hero. In the poem beowulf kills grendel's mother. Certainly he is interested in increasing his reputation and gaining honor and payment for his own king back in Geatland. However, we soon learn that a major motivation is a family debt that Beowulf owes to Hrothgar. In both movie and poem he fights for glory and honor but also so people will remember his name for being the one who has killed all this monster. In the movie beowulf has a soft spot for women. Beowulf has a kid with Grendel's mother in the movie. Beowulf lied about killing Grendel's mother in the movie but in the poem he killed her. In the poem beowulf is loyal and true of his word. Like in the poem he is a hero and has no soft spot for anything or one and not like in the movie he has soft spot for women and sleeps with his bed warmer and not his…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays