Preview

Battle of the Sexes: the Manly Man

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
938 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Battle of the Sexes: the Manly Man
Battle of the Sexes: The Manly Man

The concept of being a man, and the idea of manliness, has been debatable in recent decades due to acts of feminism. Paul Theroux wrote Being a Man and was very opinionated as he said the idea of manliness was wrong and oppressive. Harvey Mansfield wrote The Partial Eclipse of Manliness, and stated that the concept of being manly has diminished and been overpowered by feminism. Both of these readings have provided valid and doubtful points in the discussion of what constitutes being manly, as well as how North American culture views the stereotypical man. Both authors are very opinionated and biased in their readings as they do not have any outside sources supporting their beliefs, but they do make effective arguments which further their attitude and outlook on manliness.
In Paul Theroux’s reading Being a Man, it is stated that man can be categorized as stupid, arrogant, and much like pre-historic cavemen. Theroux continued to say that if someone were born as a man, there would be limits of what he is physically, emotionally, and mentally capable of. His highly personal view of how men act relates to a time when men were expected to aspire to be the so-called perfect man. The stereotypical perfect man is theoretically defined as brash, built, strong, athletic, and overall a poor loser when it involves any form of competition. It is also claimed that the typical man should be stupid, unfeeling, obedient, and ultimately soldierly. Theroux argued that these qualities eventually create poor husbands, sadists, and potentially rapists. Although this could happen, it is very unlikely that the majority of men with those characteristics will end up malicious and violent like Theroux stated.
Mansfield’s approach to the deterioration of masculinity faulted women. He believed manliness is dubious as women over the years have been referred to with manly intentions. He felt that feminism has not only succeeded, but dominated



Cited: Mansfield, Harvey. “The Partial Eclipse of Manliness.” Reproductive Health Matters 6.12 (1998): 116-21. Print. Theroux, Paul. “Being a Man.” Culture and Identity. Ed. Paula Fredeman. Minneapolis: U of Minnesota P, 2006. 133-35. Print.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    “Manhood” was a very sociological and physiological concept. In the antebellum period, manhood was based upon one’s inner self and how he acted as a Christian gentlemen. By the end of the nineteenth century, manhood was defined by aggressiveness and physical control. Men found control through physical violence, which was the exclusive domain of men and men only. Men used violence to confirm the status of their manhood in the years of the Civil War, the terror campaign of the KKK, and America’s Imperial expansion in the late 19th century. The actions of men during these times were built upon their conception of “manhood” as being physically tough and aggressive.…

    • 1323 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What does it mean to be a “man?” Unfortunately, in American culture this is all too important of a question. According to sociologist, Michael Kimmel, being a (white) man entails having much anger, violence, and entitlement, which he describes further in his book: Angry White Men. These actions are also displayed in the 2007 film, The Departed, which follows the story of two white men on their journey to take on the Irish Mob along with the Massachusetts State Police Department. But, where do these actions come from? In this paper, I will be arguing that men in today’s society act out while trying to fulfill the ideal masculine role that is shaped by American society’s social expectations and social institutions including the family,…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Manhood in western societies is pre-programmed, pre-packaged and forced-fed to boys from birth to adulthood. Historically the puriest example of a real man was the military standard. Military manliness dictates that a man must be strong, both physically and mentally, a man must be unfeeling and must be loyal to their fellow commrades. Men must show a certain level of respect for women but never acknowledge them as equal.…

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dave Barry’s Guys vs. Men is a humorous essay that describes the major characteristics of “guyhood” even though he admits he can’t define exactly what it means to be a ‘guy’. In the essay, Barry uses plenty of gender stereotypes of men, guys, and women. His take on the existence of gender is comical. For instance, he says that “If God did not want us to make gender-based generalizations, She would not have given us genders”.…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I agree that the dominant form of masculinity and femininity are changing, however, this change has been going on for several generations now. Women are becoming the breadwinners while a lot of fathers are becoming stay-at-home dads. Some of the changes that come with women taking on more masculine jobs is the way that they dress. Since many jobs require respect women have gone from wearing dresses and cute hairstyles to wearing pants and cutting their hair off short to appear more dominating. On page 296 in our book the author points out that our society today actually promotes “tough femininity” as a lot of today’s actresses are seen taking on the more masculine…

    • 115 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Cited: Bordo, Susan "Gender Matters: Gentleman or Beast? The Double Blind of Masculinity" Keller 163-174.…

    • 1557 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    guys vs. men

    • 2052 Words
    • 6 Pages

    But men tend to attach great significance to Manhood. This results in certain characteristically masculine, by which I mean stupid, behav­ioral patterns that can produce unfortunate results such as violent crime, war, spitting, and ice hockey. These things have given males a bad name. And the "Men's Movement," which is supposed to bring out the more positive aspects of Manliness, seems to be densely populated with loons and goobers.…

    • 2052 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Masculinity

    • 1025 Words
    • 5 Pages

    A cowboy, the strong and silent “man’s man” is the iconic figure of masculinity. The same cowboy also has a certain fragileness. The perception of a man usually does not reveal the fragile side. However, Gretel Ehrlich reveals this underlying soft side of cowboys in About Men (1985), and Paul Theroux explains in Being a Man (1985) that the idea of manhood is pitiful because there is a fragile side to every man.…

    • 1025 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “What I’ve been saying (and believing without realizing it) is that male value ultimately depends on reducing women to physical symbols of masculine superiority,” (Godsey 121). He makes continual references to the suffering that women have endured for decades, due to mans’ pleasures, and then abruptly returns to the society today. This exemplifies Godsey’s own personal confusion referencing his self- stability, causing doubt as to his credibility on the matter he chose to discuss, and his persona in general (ethos). As Godsey furthers to rant and rave about the mistreatment of men and the standards of masculinity that men must live to today, he completes each idea with attacks similar to “It’s like I’m a woman. My self-esteem frequently depends on how I see my body,” (Godsey 117). By making such obnoxious accusations, Godsey’s effectiveness plummets. He argues for the sake of women and their mistreatment by society, and then whips around and makes the worst of stereotypical announcements and on the behalf of women.…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The image of Man has changed throughout time. Dominant constructions of masculinity, which are basically attempts to stabilize gender identity, are developed within the dynamics of shifting cultures and societies. The male stereotype, which is still prevails nowadays, started rising at the end of eighteenth – beginning nineteenth century in Europe with a great concentration on the male’s body. The stereotype made the world look at man more like a type rather than an individual. Masculinity was strengthened due to the positive stereotyping, however for those that did not conform to this label or fit in with the ideal, were negatively stereotyped.…

    • 2248 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hewat, A. J. (1999). The Men They Will Become: The Nature and Nurture of Male…

    • 1997 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tough Guise

    • 737 Words
    • 3 Pages

    What does it mean to be a man in society? Jackson Katz in the documentary “Tough Guise” argues that social media puts a lot of pressure on how men should look and act. For example, Arnold Schwarzenegger is possibly one of the most popular role models for young boys and men today. Therefore when our society thinks of the ultimate “many man” the first thing that comes to mind is strong, aggressive, tall, handsome, courageous, rough, tough, emotionless, insensitive, fearless and practical. Men should not be soft, submissive or weak. If a man would show weakness in any way, there would be much criticism to follow. People fail to realize how their cultural expectations can be harmful to boys, men, women, and society as a whole. Our culture needs to be more excepting of what it “truly” means to be a man.…

    • 737 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    During the twentieth century there have been several leading studies, findings and theories to attempt to rationalize and explain masculinity and gender roles in the United States. Some have been based on biblical reference, others on pure animal instinct and some based on modern research. In the following pages I will describe my own factors and qualities that define what it means to be man; that is to understand modern masculinity in the United States. I will highlight and further explore the common theme of hegemonic masculinity and how it threads into our modern culture. You will see a “frameless framework” evolve; one that is not visible directly, rather it becomes visible only through the absence of tangible visual clues. In addition, I will explore the intersectionality of several roles the Western culture uses to define ourselves as men. Along the way I have included historical references to show how this has changed. In the end you will have a better understanding about intended, conscious choices as well as those unintended, more subtle elements which define modern Western masculinity.…

    • 4571 Words
    • 19 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Masculinity

    • 1014 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The search for becoming a man begins the moment young Johnny realizes he is different from his counterpart Jane. At this epiphany the search begins to find out his true identity. As Johnny’s eyes are open to his manhood he departs on a lifelong journey into his masculinity. What the young boy doesn’t know is that along the way he will be faced with many false ideologies of manhood. The biggest culprit lies in the portrayal of men in the media. The media is saturated with male role models. However the underlining message preached from the media is that of a hyper masculinity and not a proper view of what a man is to become. The media promotes an unhealthy representation of true manhood.…

    • 1014 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Masculinity is a concept built on a set of characteristics and behaviours, which are generally considered to be typical or appropriate for men. Many tend to comprehend masculinity as a necessity, without it there is no purpose of being called a “man”. In Toni Morrison's Beloved, the protagonist; Paul D, is portrayed as a kind and meditative personality, he lived a life of a lonely wanderer, someone so unsettled that he cannot really develop as a man. Originally, his memories at Sweet Home cause questions to arise in his mind pertaining to his manhood because of all the situations that made him feel like he was diminished and was not given much opportunity to experience the process of growing into the manhood stages. A situation that resembles…

    • 316 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics