Preview

Article Critique on Diversity

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
726 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Article Critique on Diversity
Background Information
Arthur: Anne-Marie Guillemard
Title: Concluding Remarks Company Practices and Public Policies Regarding Age:
Lesson Drawn from Comparisons.
Source: The Geneva Papers on Rick and Insurance Vol. 28 No. 4
Year: 2003

Thesis
An observation on the trend in the reduction in economic activity after age 55 in various countries, and how the varying degrees of public policies in these countries impact that trend.

Methods
Using other published articles as reference, a comparison of the public policies in Japan, Switzerland, France, Germany, United Kingdom, and Canada were compared to 1) explain diversity among countries and the policies for managing ageing work forces, 2) to show applicable remedies to convince firms to keep older workers.

Evidence of Thesis Support
The author offered a comprehensive approach to the trends and illustrated the connection between the company practices and these trends, even if not always equally thorough. Despite the strength in making those comparisons, the author did not reach his full potential, while the diversity was presented in the studies, the results were loss because the articles were cited in one main paragraph so there was no connection between and country and where the information was derived. The supporting evidence was confusing and ambiguous, in an overview of employment/unemployment policies towards older workers the similarities and differences between countries needed to be clearly identified.
The remedies were equally limited, an adjustment to the procedures for assigning employees to jobs and motivating workers was one of the remedies, however those procedures were not illustrate in the article. Further, the public policy that the author advocates as having little success has not been identified. To get insight and gain a better understanding one would have to read all the individual articles on which this one was formed

Contribution to the Literature
Contributions which



Cited: Blank, R. M. (1994). Social Protection versus Economic Flexibility: Is There a Trade-off. Chicago: Universty of Chicago Press. Gill Kirton, A.-M. G. (2001). The Dynamics of Managing Diversity. Woburn: Butterworth-Heinemann.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Res 351

    • 3122 Words
    • 13 Pages

    Age discrimination is existent. Older employees are defined as members of the “mature” generation (58 or more years old); younger employees are members of three generations—the Baby Boom (post World War II or 38 – 57 year olds), Generation X (23 – 37 year olds), and Generation Y (18 – 22 year olds). “The key to a company’s future success will be its adaptability – its capacity to deploy resources quickly to seize competitive opportunities and to draw from a labor pool that features a mix of multi-skilled, full-time workers, and specifically-skilled, contingent employees who contribute on a part-time or temporary basis” (Hall and Mirvis, 1998). Research is conducted when individuals or businesses want to find out the connection, if any, between two or more things. This paper will discuss, “Will hiring younger employees to take the place of older employees increase the productivity of a business?”…

    • 3122 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Employment Law Paper

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Age discrimination occurs when someone of a certain age or age group is denied hiring or a promotion because of their age. “The age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA) prohibits employers of 20 or more people from refusing to hire, paying less to, discharging, or otherwise discriminating, against employees because of their age” (Barnes, Dworkin, Richards, 2003, p 374). There are only 16 employees in the age range of 50-59 and 5 employees in the 60 and over category. There are also only 27 employees in the age range of 18-29 with none of these employees being executives. The other categories 30-39 and 40-49 have the most number of employees with 41 and 36 respectively. As a manager the ethical and legal obligation to the employee is to offer equal jobs for everyone in the work place who is capable of doing the job. At the same time, management should not force employees who are older to retire if the employee is not ready to retire. While employers cannot force an employee to retire if they are capable of completing the job, they can expect an employee to retire early for inability to perform the job.…

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Encel, S 1999, ‘Age Discrimination in Employment in Australia’, Ageing International, vol. 25, no. 2, pp. 69-84.…

    • 1494 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In 1946, America received its first round of baby boomers that continued for the course of 18 years in which more than seventy-nine million babies were born. With that being said, most of the first round of baby boomers are turning 66 this year while the last flood of baby boomers will turn 48 (About.com.Geography ). With this becoming a reality for many employers it is no wonder that management faces many new challenges. However, this challenge is around to stay. Many employers are faced with the first wave of baby boomers to have faced retirement last year and many more to come in the following years. This is alarming because in order to receive full retirement benefits you must be 65, however, you may start receiving benefits at the age of 62. In 1983, the government passed a law making the retirement age gradually higher until those born after 1959 will need to be 67 to receive full retirement benefits (Social Security Online). The havoc this creates for management is the fact that it with the retirement age increasing it means that employers must find way to keep the aging workforce satisfied. With this comes many challenges including learning how to manage an aging workforce, training the elder employees to ever changing rules and regulations, and training the new employees that are taking over positions.…

    • 1793 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Elderly people (women and men age sixty-five or older) (Macionis, 2005), Have many obstacles to face as they grow older, many of these obstacles involve social inequality. Not only do the elderly have to learn to deal with many forms of Ageism (the stereotyping and prejudice against individuals or groups because of their age), some also have to deal with the fact that they do not have enough savings or pension benefits to be self supporting, for most people over sixty-five, the major source of income is social security (Macionis, 2005). This forces many elderly Americans back into the workforce to continue to earn money to support themselves and or spouses. Although many elderly Americans may choose to work into later stages of their life for personal satisfaction, some choose to continue work for lack of money, and may be discriminated against in the workforce by facing ageism. Once out of the workforce, the elderly population may also have to face poverty and elderly abuse.…

    • 1105 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Best Essays

    is mutually beneficial. It allows employees to achieve job security and income predictability, and to…

    • 4858 Words
    • 20 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    This is especially true for the employment sector, where employers have failed to take advantage of the skilled labor force available from this population. Often, employers perceive older adults as fitting into one profile, not realizing that similar to the rest of the population, each senior citizen is unique, has unique skills as well as capabilities and needs. When this is taken into account, it means that some employers have been able to carefully select older workers to fill specific positions within the organization. I myself have had the privilege to work in various organizations during my senior years and had the opportunity to positively contribute to the wellbeing of society. Individuals aged above 50 years old are still running large companies in senior management positions while others are still able to work in labor intensive industries such as manufacturing and…

    • 923 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    While putting forward the principle-based argument that age discrimination of elderly work candidates is morally wrong, the paper discusses the consequences of hiring elderly and also common misperceptions of these consequences and of elder workers’ capabilities. Conflicting economical and social values are identified and discussed, affected interest groups are considered, and a possible solution - applying a tax allowance for companies that hire elder people – is presented and its effects on the different interest groups are considered in this report as well. Additionally, a hypothetical calculation model of what such a policy would cost to the government with explanations is included, and also benefits and costs to various stakeholders are looked upon. The few currently implemented government incentives to deal with this issue are reviewed, as well as possible alternative solutions apart from a tax allowance. Conclusions are given at the end, the main result being that there is a need for further state support to the elderly in the labour market, and a tax allowance being found to be the most suitable means for that in Latvia. The information used is mainly derived from published material in form of internet publications, relevant textbooks, and personal interviews with managers of companies and the elderly employees.…

    • 5333 Words
    • 22 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Firstly, under the pressure of the knowledge economy, the requirement of continuous innovation and creativity demands employees for certain competences such as self-motivation or flexibility which cannot be found in the middle-aged workers. This deficiency slows down the pace of working process. Hence, the retirement of the old employees is necessary for employment opportunities of younger people which helps to reduce youth unemployment and offer advantageous conditions for young people to perform their talent.…

    • 281 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Outdated human resource policies threaten the companies intellectual capital as the amount of employees retires on a fastening pace. It is also known fact that the social costs of retirement are going to skyrocket and there are only structural measures which can compensate or at least mitigate the costs. Working later into old age, accelerating productivity growth and initiating mentorship programs can compensate the effects of aging. The negative effects are real, but so are the opportunities as well. The wealth and income is going to accumulate to the older population, and the willingness of consume is greater than in the generations before them. For majority of industries the shift to older customer can be seen as a huge possibility, if the needs and desires of older consumers will be identified.…

    • 3002 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The relationship between age and job performance is of great importance because it is believed that job performance decreases as age increases. Though not all employers have perceptions of older employees. From a positive perspective it is noted that older employees have more experience, judgment, ethics and commitment. In addition, with older employees, labour turnover is reduced. Because of their longer tenure within the organization they tend to enjoy increased wages, pension and many other benefits and are therefore less likely to leave. With regards to absenteeism and older employees, the evidence is however mixed. Although there are decreases in avoidable absenteeism rates compared to younger employees, there is an increase in unavoidable rates due to poor health due to age, and longer recovery periods. However from a negative point it is noted that older employees lack flexibility, there is a decrease in their productivity due to decreased speed, agility, strength and co-ordination and resistance to change in a changing environment. Consequently, organizations are reluctant to hire older employees. In addition, they tend to retrench them first when it comes to downsizing.…

    • 6651 Words
    • 27 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ageing Workforce

    • 438 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Demographic trends indicate that older workers cannot be overlooked as a key source of labour supply in globally shrinking labour markets. As stated in current research numerous comparative studies have been undertaken to evaluate the intergenerational differences in work ethic and productivity between baby boomers and younger workers (Buyens, Van Dijk, Dewilde & De Vos, 2009; Koc Menard, 2009 & Loretto, 2006). Australian national data show that older workers (aged 45 and over) are consistently disadvantaged in the labour market in the recruitment/retention cycle compared to younger workers (Buyens et al 2009).…

    • 438 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lining

    • 419 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In many places today, especially in some developed countries, the phenomenon of aging society has shown up. However, because it is more likely that neither the government policy nor the system of serving elderly people has三 been established completely, there are a lot of society problems exposed.…

    • 419 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In conclusion, in spite of partial causes elderly people could keep working in top rank companies unless they feel like staying home. In addition, hardly ever can any business survive without experienced and highly qualified staff.…

    • 609 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    By 2040, this ratio is expected to increase to 38.7%; elder being defined as 65+ and youth as 15-64 (210). The cut-off into elder hood is not an arbitrary one; rather, it is chosen as the age in which one can leave the labor market due to one’s age alone, and become eligible for pension. When faced with a low birthrate and increasing tax burdens on a nation’s youth to fund care for its elders, drawing on a pool of capable workers to increase the laborers in the market is increasingly a very viable option. With average life expectancies for Danish women pushing 80, and men trailing behind at just under 75 years of age, questioning the value of retiring people who are, on average, perfectly capable of working for possibly ten or more years becomes relevant. Mind you, this is an average age of death; where it used to be uncommon to meet a person in their 80s, nonagenarians have become increasingly commonplace, with more than a fair few centenarians floating around. Hastrup says, “According to many gerontologists, the ageing begins around the age of 65… It happens slowly and individually and people hardly notice it until it has already reached an advanced stage. So you do not become unfit for work when you reach the age of 65, even though the effects of age may be beginning to show” (75). Between 1950 and 2005, the number of octogenarians has increased by 508% worldwide; this is not a statistical anomaly (95).…

    • 1411 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays