Preview

Anti-Catholic Sentiment in 19th Century America

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1334 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Anti-Catholic Sentiment in 19th Century America
The Contradictory American Identity in the Eyes of Nativists

Lauren Krueger
Professor Schneider
WR150 Writing and Research Seminar
6 January 2015

As far back as the 1800’s, America has been defined as a nation of immigrants, or a “melting pot”. During this century, millions of foreign-born people entered the ports of the United States, seeking work, political refuge, and religious freedom. Immigrants from Europe came in massive waves. As immigration rates increased, a group now known as nativists emerged, who, although of European stock, antagonized the newer Irish Catholic immigrants. Examining the opposition towards Irish immigrants furthers our understanding of nativists’ idea of their ‘American’ community by revealing what this sentiment was based on and why. As seen in political cartoons of the age, Irish Catholic immigrants were presented as and consequently viewed as threats to the national community based on the principle that America’s exceptionalism was founded on its powerful ideals set by the first European Protestants in the colonial period. This principle is essential to understand, as it has a continuing influence in American foreign policy to this day. The ideals held by the nativists were embellished with powerful titles such as “Protestantism”, “republicanism”, etc. but remained ambiguous. Historian Michael W. Hughey details this by explaining that “Americanism cannot be easily defined in terms of what it is, it has often been defined in terms of what it is not-i.e., with reference to those who are presumed to be its enemies”.1 In the mid-19th century, nativists were especially hostile to the Irish Catholic immigrants as they were viewed as fundamentally un-American, due to their their supposed allegiance to their home countries and the Roman Catholic church. Nativists believed immigrants would maintain views that would alter an already established ‘culture’, concerning facets such as the public education system, social morality,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Immigrants from all over the world make the journey to America for many different reasons but with one goal in common, a better life, and they have been doing so for centuries. What makes America what it is today is it’s diversity, a “melting pot” of cultures and traditions coming together as one. But this is not how the White Anglo Saxon Protestants from the 19th century (WASPs) viewed it. WASPs did everything in their power to keep immigrant groups like the “dirty Chinese” and “violent Irish Catholics” out, giving them negative stereotypes and creating laws to mark them as an inferior race. In the political cartoons “The Irish Declaration of Independence That We Are All familiar With” and “The Only One Barred Out” it is clear that the artists are portraying how…

    • 1625 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Until the 1880s, most of the immigrants had come from the British Isles and Western Europe (Germany and Scandinavia) and were quite literate and accustomed to some type of representative government. This was called the “Old Immigration.” But by the 1880s and 1890s, this shifted to the Baltic and Slavic people of southeastern Europe, who were basically the opposite, “New Immigration.” Many Europeans came to America because there was no room in Europe, nor was there much employment, since industrialization had eliminated many jobs. The “nativism” and anti-foreignism of the 1840s and 1850s came back in the 1880s, as the Germans and western Europeans looked down upon the new Slavs and Baltics, fearing that a mixing of…

    • 1276 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Author David Cole explains in "Five Myths about Immigration" that people are misinformed about immigrants in America and blame them for all the problems in the American society. Cole comments that the "Native Americans", which have nothing to do with what we call Native Americans today, were labeled as "Know-Nothings" because they simply did not know anything about immigrants and prejudged immigrants who came into the country. The author quotes one "Know-Nothing" for saying that "more than half the prisons and almshouses, more than half the police and the cost of administering criminal justice are for foreigners." In the 1860s, immigrants arrived from Ireland and Germany causing "anti-alien and anti-Catholic sentiments" to appear in states such as Massachusetts and New York. Cole takes this topic to heart because his ancestors were among the "dirt-poor Irish-Catholics" who moved to America in the 1960s but were fortunate because after fifteen years the prejudice faded away. Now, 140 years later, the author points out that a similar prejudice has returned with the exception that the focus has changed from "Irish Catholics and Germans" to "Latin Americans (most recently, Cubans), Haitians, and Arab-Americans." Cole explains how five commonly held beliefs regarding immigrants to the United States, are in reality "myths."…

    • 929 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    With the alleged increasing influx of immigrants the intensification of racism and nativism has taken a new shape and seeped into the media, as well as local, state, and federal policy. Particularly, the escalation of nativism is concentrated at Latinos, and has thus, created an issue of illegality. In addition, nativism, an adverse outlook on foreign individuals, has remained molded by dynamics that shift with historical occurrences and has influenced anti-immigrant sentiments (Higham, 2002, 3).…

    • 282 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Cited: Carnes, Mark C., and John A. Garraty. The American Nation: A History of the United States. New York: Pearson Longman, 2006. Print.…

    • 1215 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the Gilded Age when America was becoming more industrialized, the U.S was seen as the land of opportunity to many people in Europe and Asia. During the mid to late 1800s, “Old immigrants” from Western Europe had originally come to America to dig in the goldfields and help build the transcontinental railroads in the West. After them, came the “new immigrants”, from Southern and Eastern Europe. Although both were very culturally different, they had the same intents when coming to America and got the same negative responses from nativists.…

    • 522 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Beginning in the early nineteenth century there were massive waves of immigration. Immigrants were mostly from Italy, Russia, and Ireland. There was a mixed reaction to these incoming foreigners. While they provided industries with a cheap source of labor, Americans were both afraid of, and hostile towards these new groups. They differed from the "typical American" in language, customs, and religion and took many jobs of Americans. Many individuals and industries alike played upon America's…

    • 641 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Untied States of America is commonly labeled or thought of as the melting pot of the world where diverse groups of people flock to in order to better their current lives. In our countries history this has proven to primarily be our way of living and how the people as a nation view immigration. However, in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries this open door mentality was quite the opposite to what the majority of people felt towards the idea of welcoming these huddled masses. Immigrants were not seen as equals or people willing to work hard for a better life but rather a diseased parasite that would suck the prosperous and prestigious life that the old immigrants had become accustomed to. American nativist groups during this time period acted in a hypercritical manner with the impression that open immigration would, in the end cause our country to be overtaken and overrun by a far less superior race.…

    • 611 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The United States of America is one of the most diverse countries in the entire world. It has gained diversity not merely through race, but through religion, ethnic background, and through the ever-dynamic shift of America. Some of the most dramatic and rapid changes occurred in the late nineteenth century following the Civil War. As the United States began to industrialize, wave upon wave of immigrants poured into the country’s borders in search of religious, political, or, more often than not, economic freedom. To the outside world, the United States began to be seen as our Pledge of Allegiance suggests is: a land of the free. “’America is a free country’ one Polish immigrant stated…’you don’t have to be a serf to anyone…freedom and prosperity are enjoyed by the people of the United States.’”1 Despite these immigrant hopes of freedom and prosperity, America was only just beginning to leave behind its roots of slavery; racism and prejudice were still in the air. While African-American men were being given their permission to vote, white women still struggled for that freedom. Immigrants faced dilemmas from some radical white women. “Feminists argued that native-born white women deserved the vote more than non-whites and immigrants.” 2 The struggles of being an immigrant were difficult enough, but to be a woman as well during that era was unlike any other barrier to freedom and inequality at the time. The novel Bread Givers by Anzia Yezierska, an immigrant who lived during that era, discusses what life was like for her demographic during her time through the eyes of a Jewish immigrant girl. Immigrant women in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century faced a slew of harrowing challenges as they faced a changing America.…

    • 1439 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ronald Takaki retells the American history from the bottom up, through the lives of many minorities. The stories of many ethnical groups who helped create America’s mighty economy and rich culture, in his book, A Different Mirror. All these indigenous people were a part of what America is today, a more multicultural country. These peoples were looking for a better life, and they helped create a concrete backbone for America’s economic structure. This led to the rise ‘market revolution’, which changed America culturally. The revolution was good for America, but for the immigrants, it was abysmal. They were not viewed as Americans, despite their efforts to make America what it is today. We will see as the Irish were deprived of their land, coming to the land of the free in search for a better life, how they later marginalize the Mexicans. The Market revolution opened the way to making America more multicultural but not all cultures were equal.…

    • 1030 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many factors influenced why Americans resented “new” immigrants, such as the decrease of jobs and increase of competition, the differences between cultures and how Americans believed that immigrants were harming the country. While how ‘nativist’ groups, along with their allies in government, responded (both politically and socially) was caused by their fear of immigrants, their view of Americans being superior to immigrants and…

    • 428 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    New Immigrants

    • 400 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Finally, the main difference and major contribution to Native-born fears was the willpower of the “New Immigrants” to preserve their culture regardless of the costs. Although the “Old Immigrants” also tried to keep their culture alive, they did this in a very minimalistic way in comparison to the restaurants, social clubs, and more that the “New Immigrants” created in an attempt to preserve their culture. This also was faced with opposition especially by antiforeign organizations such as the “American Protective Association” or APA who made every effort to prevent Roman Catholic from taking office and even suppressed the faith by depicting their nuns in “lustful fantasies.” Besides degrading the culture of the new individuals who had come to America, the Native-born also developed organized labor which emphasized the language barrier of the “New Immigrants” as a means to protect American workers and their jobs from the “inferior.” Organized Labor was not the only tactic to…

    • 400 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    John F. Kennedy once exclaimed, “Every American who ever lived, with the exception of one group, was either an immigrant himself or a descendant of immigrants(A Nation Of Immigrants page 3)." John was known for his irish-catholic heritage, and he served as one of our most beloved presidents. John A. Treutlen was the first naturalized citizen governor. Treutlen’s parents were raised with British ideals. When Treutlen went off to America to make something of himself, his parents called him worthless (D). However, he rose above his heritage to bring great ideas to American policies. Treutlen wasn’t the only citizen considered worthless. In fact many immigrants feel like this when they come to America. They want to prove to their families (and themselves) that…

    • 1595 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One specific group of immigrants have had a tremendous impact on the American society. In an article written by Tasos Vossos, who is an writer for the people of our everyday lives, he writes “According to the U.S. Catholic magazine, in 1820, Catholics were the smallest denomination in the United States, with 195,000 members. By 1860, they were the largest, rising to 3.1 million” (Vossos, 2011, para. 3). Irish Immigrants introduced a new religion and they impacted the American culture greatly. The cultural impact immigrants bring to the United States is…

    • 1679 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Federalists were apprehensive that the Irish would take jobs away from American workers and lower their wages. Furthermore, taxpayers would have to “foot the bill” for the strains the newcomers imposed civil services such as schools and hospitals. Nativists especially feared religious contamination. They claimed that the Catholicism of the Irish was alien to the Protestant values held to be indispensable to the preservation of American liberties.…

    • 460 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays