Preview

Are Eyewitness Identifications Reliable?

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1216 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Are Eyewitness Identifications Reliable?
Are Eyewitness Identifications Reliable
Guneet Singh
Roll no: 5826632
HAY 120
Introduction to Forensic Psychology

Are Eyewitnesses identifications Reliable? Eyewitness testimony is the description an onlooker gives in court, unfolding what they saw had happened at a specific occasion which is been investigated. It mainly includes identification of perpetrators or the details of the crime scene. Mainly recollection of events is detailed, but not always. This recollection is the proof to demonstrate what happened from witness’s perception. In past, Memory recall had been the most reliable source of information but recently forensic psychologists had claimed that memories and individual observations could be unreliable as it could be differently moulded, modified and biased. However, many countries are making changes in how eyewitness testimony is presented in court. Since early 20th century, many psychologists had questioned the reliability of eyewitness testimony. Its believability was first questioned by Hugo Munsterberg, who first developed the field of forensic psychology. He doubted the consistency of observation and memory in “On the Witness stand”. Eyewitness testimony is a significant region of research in cognitive psychology and human memory. Research has shown that juries are often unable to differentiate between a false and accurate eyewitness testimony. The confidence level of the witness is often seen by jurors to connect with accuracy of their statements. Psychology had built scientific literucture on eyewitness identification and cautioned justice system with the issues associated with it. Eyewitness testimony research’s looks at systematic variables or estimator variables. Estimator varibales can be categorised in four main sections: characteristics of the witness, testimony, or testimony evaluators and events. Systematic variables are variables which have or are possibility controlled by justice system. The following two

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    However, Yuille and Cuttshall’s study of real life eyewitnesses does not support the Yerkes Dodson law. They interviewed witnesses to a real life violent crime and found that witnesses near to the event had better recall of events than those further away. This study has good ecological validity because it involves a real life crime.…

    • 478 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    12 men in the jury

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I would have to say that it depends on the eye witness. A human being has been proven to sometimes see things that are not actually there and believe things that never happened. The emotions that we have make us susceptible to having our perceptions skewed and out senses tricked. There's also the issue of someone lying for personal gain. That being said, I wouldn't say that eye witness testimony isn't reliable, but it can't be seen as infallible and should be able to hold up to a certain amount of scrutiny.…

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The reliability of eyewitness identification has attracted concern from legal professions in England for a number of years, particularly following the acknowledgment of the erroneous identifications responsible for convicting Adolf Beck in 1904. The case was followed by the Establishment of the Court of Appeal in England and Wales (Bromby, MacMillan & McKellar, 2007). Mistaken eyewitness identification testimony was central to the convictions of innocents who were later exonerated by forensic DNA testing (Gary L. Wells). Although through studies information has been acquired about how to decrease the likelihood of mistaken identifications, many courts around the world still conduct identification using approaches largely unsupported by scientific…

    • 107 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In society it is substantially common for people to be exonerated for a crime they did not commit. Unfortunately it is even more common for that to happen when they are incarcerated due to inaccurate eyewitness testimonies. Eyewitness research has demonstrated that there are a multitude of ways to conduct identification processes, however, the processes that police often use today are more likely to encourage inaccurate identification. In addition there have been many case studies of exonerated people that show the downfalls of eyewitness testimony. Wrongful incarceration has consistently demonstrated that inaccurate identification carries a big weight when it comes to wrongful identification, in fact, in the article Contamination of Eyewitness Self-Reports and Mistaken-Identification Problem by Laura Smalarz and Gary L. Wells, they state that there is an average of thirty three percent of witnesses who make an identification from a lineup identify a known innocent filler. There is a lot of thought behind the processes of identification but there are so many variables that can taint a subject’s confidence.…

    • 1411 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I am completely appalled by the fact that we are still giving so much credit to the accounts of eyewitnesses. As we have learned in our studies, our memories easily become contaminated by things like, post-event misinformation, retroactive interference, errors in source monitoring, not to mention things like the stress of the event, which can also influence our memories (Matlin, 2012). If fact the act of recalling an event is more like trying to put together a puzzle with missing pieces, than simple reviewing a video. And when we take into account that “eyewitness misidentification is the greatest contributing factor to wrongful convictions proven by DNA testing, playing a role in more than 70% of convictions overturned through DNA testing…

    • 252 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This study is a replication of a study by Loftus and Palmer in 1974. The aim of the study is to test the effect of leading questions in eyewitness testimonies and how reliable the account of the witness is. The experiment uses two groups which receive two different verbs, ‘smashed’ and ‘contacted’. The method consists of an independent measure design. The independent variables are the way the words are phrased in the questions, while the dependent variable is the estimation made by the participants of the speed of the car. Random sampling is used to select the 20 high school students from ACS Cobham International School. The results consist of the mean and standard deviations of the responses participants gave. The verb ‘contacted’ had a higher mean and…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Memory and Eyewitness Testimony are two concepts which are studied within the topic of cognitive psychology. It is important to investigate these processes to aid in the understanding of how individuals cognitively process ideas and how this may affect specific behaviors. From a psychological perspective, memory can be defined as, “The capacity to retain and store information” (holah.co.uk, 2006). The further researches into the topic of memory allow it to greatly contribute toward societies' legal system, specifically in the sense of Eyewitness Testimony. Individuals may feel confident towards their memory abilities but according to many researchers, one's memory is not always reliable. (Bartlett, 1932) believed that memory is unreliable due…

    • 358 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Results from the researchers questionnaire sent to exonerated individuals, Innocence Project attorneys, and incarcerated inmates claiming innocence will be analyzed thoroughly based off the information of the individual’s charges, sentence served, reasons they were wrongfully convicted, key evidence that reversed the initial charges, and reasons that made it difficult for inmates to have access to post-conviction procedures. Feedback from the Innocence Project attorneys and incarcerated but claiming innocent inmates will also be analyzed. These results will be compared and put together for an explanation regarding the reasons that lead to wrongful convictions. Results leading to inaccurate eyewitness identification as the top reason that leads toward wrongful conviction and poor development of eyewitness identification procedures would confirm the hypothesis. However, if results showed otherwise, with inaccurate eyewitness identification as not the most common element and statistics show eyewitness identification procedures are frequently developed and improved, this type of result will disconfirm the researchers…

    • 2617 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Fivush, R. Peterson, C. & Schwarzmueller, A. (2000). 'Questions and Answers: The Credibility of Child Witnesses in the Context of Specific Questioning Techniques ', in Memory and Suggestibility in the Forensic Interview, M Eisen, J Quas & GS Goodman (eds), Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers, New Jersey.…

    • 2876 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Eyewitness psychologist have conducted controlled laboratory experiments that occur in phases. In the first phase, the encoding phase, “participants view a staged event, a video of a stimulated crime, or a photo of a target” (Smith & Dufraimont, 2014, p. 200). This phase examines how the participants process details of a memory. Phase two, the recognition phase, requires participants to identify a target using target-present or target-absent identification procedures (Smith & Dufraimont, 2014). During a target-present procedure, a participant can make one out of two decisions. The participant can make a decision to identify the target (a “hit), or make a decision to reject the target (“a miss”). Similarly, a participant can make one out of two decisions for a target-absent procedure as well. The participant can make a decision to reject the suspect (“correct rejection”), or make a decision to identify the suspect (“false alarm”). The last phase consists of making sure that the participant is confident in his or her decisions (Smith & Dufraimont, 2014). Researchers than analyze the participants’ performance by “examining the proportion of [hit and false alarm decisions made] in target-present and target-absent conditions separately” (Smith & Dufraimont, 2014, p. 202). In order for this identification procedure to be used in criminal investigations, it should produce more hits than false alarms. However, because this procedure does not produce the idea ratio researchers turn to using more diagnostic measures and procedures (Smith & Dufraimont,…

    • 1164 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Eyewitness Identification

    • 481 Words
    • 2 Pages

    "Mistakes eyewitness identification has gone for 30 years now Identifying the innocent man up to life in prison, while the real perpetrator gets away like in U.S. Supreme Court decisions in Neil v. Bigger and Manson v. Brathwaite" (Criminal Evidence Thomas J. Gardner pg. 319)…

    • 481 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    Eyewitness testimonies are a very important area within cognitive psychology and relates directly to the human brain and memory. Cognitive psychology refers to the study of an individual’s internal processes, more specifically how they perceive information, how they learn, remember and think. The way that an individual functions cognitively directly impacts the eyewitness statement that they give, as we all perceive and recall information differently. By questioning the validity of eyewitness testimonies, ultimately we are questioning in what way the function of our memory dictates how much, and what aspects of what we see are remembered. Within today’s judicial system there are many aspects involved when convicting…

    • 2373 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Better Essays

    Ron Cotton, a 22 year old man, sat in his cold, dark, 6 by 8 cell with his face engulfed in his thin pillow as he sobbed and wished for the company of his family and friends. Eight days earlier Ron Cotton was living his everyday life, working, and going to school until somehow Cotton found himself in a police identification lineup for the rape of Jennifer Thompson, a 22-year old college student. On the night of July 28th, 1984, a large male broke into Jennifer’s house pinned her down and began raping her. Remarkably, Jennifer’s first instinct was to observe specific characteristics about the individual in order to identify the man if she made it out alive. Cunningly, Jennifer escaped the grips of the rapist, determined to punish the man who raped her she went straight to the police and conducted a composite sketch. Three days later the police presented Jennifer with a facial composite lineup of possible suspects, and within five minutes Jennifer chose a picture of Ron Cotton with one hundred percent confidence. The eyewitness identification proved to be sufficient enough to convince the jury of Cotton’s guilt and sentence him to life in prison. After 11 years of rotting in his cell Ron Cotton was exonerated with the help of DNA evidence. The numbers of exonerations are on the rise and this poses the question whether eyewitness testimony is truly reliable? Research in cognitive psychology exposes major flaws in retrieval of long-term memory and studies exhibit how easily malleable our memories become when manipulated.…

    • 2191 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A great deal of research has been completed in relation to the accuracy of the eyewitness testimony given by children. This research is based largely on the issue of children’s memory and suggestibility. Peterson and Biggs (2006) ran a study that involved a selection of 90 children, aged between 2 and 13 years old. The study concentrated on the complications that can occur with specific questions being asked of children when they are in the midst of trauma, and the effects that obscurity can have on the accuracy of the evidence. “Researchers have long noted the problems with children’s understanding of the task demands” (Pg. 287) and if interviewers are permitted to take advantage of a child’s vulnerability with suggestive and misleading questions, it wouldn’t be unreasonable to deem that the results gathered would lack consistency and accuracy. A problematic factor that is inherent in child interviews is the nature of specific questions that are asked of children as there is “serious ambiguity in terminology and methodology among researchers” (Pg. 280). The results of this…

    • 1792 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Eyewitness Testimony

    • 2060 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Eyewitness identifications greatly sway both police and juries. As the Thomson example illustrates, an eyewitness identification can even outweigh a strong alibi supported by other testimony. This is sometimes unfortunate because eyewitness memory is highly fallible. Memory errors fall into two classes: people can 1) either completely fail to recall an event or 2) have an inaccurate recollection. People have very different attitudes about the two types of failure. Most people understand that total memory failures are common. They can introspect about occasions when they have been unable to recall an event, so failures by other people are hardly surprising. In contrast, people are overly optimistic about the accuracy of their retrieved memories, probably because most errors have little practical consequence and go unnoticed. Given the confidence in their own memory accuracy, people have too much faith in the accuracy of eyewitnesses. Memory has a multitude of quirks and inaccuracies that creep into its everyday operation. Here, I describe some basic background on memory and on the types of memory distortions that are common.…

    • 2060 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics