Too Far Ahead of the IT Curve?
Peachtree Healthcare’s patchwork IT infrastructure is in critical condition. Should the CEO approve a shift to risky new technology or go with the time-tested monolithic system?
by John P. Glaser
after their squash game, Max Berndt drank iced tea with his board chairman, Paul Leﬂer. Max, a thoracic surgeon by training, was the CEO of Peachtree Healthcare. He’d occupied the post for nearly 12 years. In that time the company had grown – mainly by mergers – from a single teaching hospital into a regional network of 11 large and midsize institutions, supported by ancillary clinics, physician practices, trauma centers, rehabilitation facilities, and nursing homes. Together, these entities had nearly 4,000 employed and afﬁliated physicians, who annually treated a million patients from throughout Georgia and beyond. The patients ranged in age from newborn to nonagenarian; represented all races, ethnicities, lifestyles, and economic conditions; and manifested every imaginable injury and disease. Many of them, over the course of a year, would be seen at more than one Peachtree Healthcare facility. Max’s marching orders were to ensure quality, consistency, and continuity of care across the entire network – and to RESHLY SHOWERED AND COOLING DOWN
HBR’s cases, which are ﬁctional, present common managerial dilemmas and offer concrete solutions from experts.
Harvard Business Review 29
MANAGING FOR THE LONG TERM
HBR CASE STUDY
Too Far Ahead of the IT Curve?
deliver all that with the highest levels of efﬁcacy, economy, and respect for patients and staff. Max, still sweating lightly, ﬁnished his tea and ordered more. He and Paul commiserated over the steady vanishing of squash courts in the metro Atlanta area. This particular block of four courts was located in a health club not far from Peachtree’s Marietta headquarters. Apart from the one Max and Paul had used, the other three were dark. “By next week,” Paul predicted, “at least one of those courts is gone.” In Paul Leﬂer’s worldview, things always happened fast. Paul was the CEO
achieve them. Paul – like other board members and some in Max’s management inner circle – was applying constant pressure on Max to follow the example of others in the health care industry: Push ahead on standards and on the systems and processes to support them. “You’ve got all the hospitals doing things differently. You’ve got incompatible technology that’s held together by sweat and ingenuity and, possibly, prayer. Just do what other institutions are doing. Common systems, broad standardization… It’s the competitive reality, and it’s the right long-term play! So, what the hell are you waiting for?” But then the iced tea
ized practices could have scary patientsafety consequences, and physicians had to be free to form their own judgments about which treatments were best for which patients. Lately, however, worrisome developments were eroding Max’s conﬁdence that he could hold out against Paul’s brute-force prescription.
Remember The African Queen?
Days before, there had been a meltdown of the clinical information system at Wallis Memorial Hospital in Decatur. (Wallis was Peachtree’s most recent addition.) Since Max had been lunching with his chief information ofﬁcer, Candace Markovich, when the alarm came through to her PDA, he drove her over to Wallis to investigate. On the way, Candace reprised her concerns about ensuring uptime and performance quality across Peachtree’s patchwork infrastructure. “More and more, I feel like Humphrey Bogart in The African Queen, trying to keep the blasted engine running on the boat,” she said. “So much of our energy and budget goes into just treading water. And the more we grow, the worse it gets.” At Wallis, Max saw cold panic on the faces of the IT staff as they rushed around trying to repair and reboot the system....