Preview

natural law

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
10309 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
natural law
NATURAL LAW
ROBERT P. GEORGE*

Oliver Wendell Holmes, the legal philosopher and judge whom Richard Posner has, with admiration, dubbed “the
American Nietzsche,”1 established in the minds of many people a certain image of what natural law theories are theories of, and a certain set of reasons for supposing that such theories are misguided and even ridiculous. While I have my own reasons for admiring some of Holmes’s work—despite, rather than because of, the Nietzscheanism that endears him to Judge Posner—I think that everything Holmes thought and taught about natural law is wrong. I have elsewhere set forth a detailed critique of Holmes’s thought,2 which I will not repeat here.
Rather, this Article offers a constructive account of what natural law theories are in fact theories of, explains why the idea of natural law and natural rights is far more plausible than people influenced by Holmes have supposed, and shows how natural law theories are similar to and different from leading compet* McCormick Professor of Jurisprudence; Director, James Madison Program in
American Ideals and Institutions, Princeton University. I originally presented this
Article as the 2007 John Dewey Lecture in Philosophy of Law at Harvard Law
School on April 9, 2007. I am deeply grateful to Dean Elena Kagan and the faculty of Harvard Law School for the honor of being invited to return to my alma mater for this occasion. I was introduced to the project of philosophical reflection on law and legal systems, and on the complex web of relationships between law and morality, by my teachers at Harvard: Lewis Sargentich, Charles Fried, Richard
Parker, Henry Steiner, Harold Berman, Dan Coquillette, and Roberto Unger. They launched me on what became my life’s work. I owe them an enormous debt of gratitude, and it is a pleasure to be able to acknowledge it here. Some material in this Article originally appeared in an interview I gave that was published as Natural Law and Human

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    I believe that Natural Laws should be the determining factor of what is just and moral regarding man made laws. Any rational person can distinguish right from wrong, but there are those who cannot and therefore that’s where man made laws come in hand. For instance the Comanche society believed it is a husband’s right to kill his wife without reasonable cause (Inciardi, 2010, p. 29). For a rational person this is insane, thus we make laws to prohibit acts to those natures. Natural laws are the laws god has instilled into all of us as a way to govern ourselves, and we should use those as guidelines for our own laws. Sure things have changed with technology and the way we view the world but for the most part the natural laws have not changed.…

    • 750 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    PHL 612: Philosophy of Law

    • 5890 Words
    • 24 Pages

    PHL 612 Philosophy of Law [Calendar Description]: What is law? What makes something a legal norm? Should citizens always obey the law? What is the relationship between law and morality? This course will explore competing theories of law, such as natural law and positivism, and touch on crucial debates over civil disobedience, purposes of punishment, and interpretation of legal texts. It will deal with contemporary controversies over the legal regulation of human behaviour, for instance in matters of sexual morality.…

    • 5890 Words
    • 24 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    The theory of natural law originates from Aristotle’s idea of goodness as fitness for purpose and stoic’s concept of a universal law of reason which is in agreement with nature. What we now call human nature. This point is then furthered by Aquinas who agrees with the argument but furthers it by linking it with his Christian belief by saying following this law is equivalent to following the command of God as human nature is in us inbuilt into us from when God created us.…

    • 1800 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Porter, J. (2010) Ministers of the Law: A Natural Law Theory of Legal Authority. Michigan: Wm. B. Erdmans Publishing Co.…

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    I am honored to be among the lecturers in this series on natural law. Many of the speakers are among my heroes and friends. One of my heroes, Alasdair MacIntyre, used one of his favorite terms in his talk: he spoke of "plain persons" and their grasp of morality and natural law in contradistinction to the experts and professional philosophers and their grasp of these matters. A few years ago in Dallas he gave a talk entitled "Do plain persons need to be moral philosophers?" When I was asked to give the response to his talk, I was most honored because I considered Prof. MacIntyre one of the foremost moral philosophers in the world and it was a thrill to comment on his work. I felt dreadfully underqualified — I felt like some high school kid going up against Larry Bird — until I realized that I need not respond as an expert, as a moral philosopher of his caliber, but that I could respond as the quintessential plain person — for that is what I am. After all, I am Janet Smith, daughter of John and Anne Smith; I grew up at 5 Hill Street and went to Home Street School — I could go on but it is all very plain.The point I am making here is not merely a flip one — designed to ease us into more serious matters through an attempt at humor. There is a serious point here — natural law, is the "plain person's" morality — in a sense it is simply plain old common sense. There are profound and sophisticated ways at explaining natural law, but the practiceof reasoning in accord with natural law principals, according to the theory itself, is natural to plain persons — that is, natural to all mankind for natural law holds that many of the most fundamental principles of moral reasoning are obvious, that is easily known by all. Yet, in spite of the plain commonsensicalness of natural law, it can seem shocking and provocative in many ways, for like natural law, plain old common sense does not command a lot of followers these days and can…

    • 6621 Words
    • 27 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Explain Natural Law Theory

    • 1143 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In this essay, I will discuss the theories behind Natural Law, as well as the qualities it is seen to possess. I will explain Aquinas’ concepts and theory on Natural Law, discussing eudaimonia and the doctrine of the double effect. Finally, I will reflect on some of the positive and negative aspects, in summarising Natural Law theory.…

    • 1143 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Natural Law can be traced back into the Ancient Greek and Roman worlds. In Sophocles' play 'Antigone', Natural Law is very apparent throughout and the writings of the Greek Philosopher; Aristotle. In his works - 'Nicomachean Ethics' - he wrote;…

    • 664 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The issue here is the possible problem in distinguishing injustice from manifest injustice – but this is question of legal certainty. Natural law’s substantive thesis is that in the case of extreme injustice, the problem of morality is also a problem of legality. It cannot be attacked merely with a formal argument charging lack of clarity.…

    • 2753 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Natural Law is an ethical system based on the view that humans have asset of natural inclinations…

    • 1604 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Natural Law is an ethical theory which states that there are unchanging laws set in the nature of the world, to tell humans what is moral and immoral. These laws are set by a supernatural power which is God. Natural Law is a Deontological theory which looks at the action to be moral despite the consequences it brings. The theory of Natural Law has been around for centuries and has had many key figures that have made key contributions to the theory.The first was a group of Greek philosophers called stoics and the Greek philosopher Aristotle to Thomas Aquinas in the 13nth century.…

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the eighteen hundreds two influential philosophers were born thirty eight years apart. Although John Stuart Mill and Friedrich Nietzsche’s lives overlapped; they both have different views regarding moral belief and the basis of morals in life. One aspect that sets these two philosophers apart is that while in London, Mill continued to fight for equal rights for women; the Germany resident, Nietzsche, believed that women were infinitely inferior to men. This, however, was not the only factor that separated these two minds.…

    • 1356 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    According to Boyd (2007), natural law states that there is a clear connection between law and morality; if the law is not based on justice then it is rendered invalid and should not be classed as law. Furthermore, Boyed (2007) posits that natural law has a long history that can be dated back to more than 2500 years ago in the context of Western development. This connection between law and morality serves as an impetus for human rights and social justice. For example, Boyd (2007) highlights the case between R. v. Caine. Caine postulated that incarceration regarding the possession of marijuana is tantamount to a violation of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, as such it is unconstitutional and in essence an affront to democracy and our civil liberties.…

    • 1388 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Natural law, although it does not demand perfect justice, is a reflection of the eternal and divine law as appropriate to the nature of its subjects. It is demonstrated through rational creatures who operate on their own reason and will in accordance with nature under the governance of eternal law. All rational creatures hold knowledge of the natural law because it is bestowed in their minds by God. Natural law, because it rules rational creatures, is based on the self-evident principles of practical reason to order ist subjects to their ends. As the first principle of practical reason is the nature of seeking good, “the first precept of natural law is that we should do and seek good, and shun evil” (Regan, 43). The precepts of natural law also reflect the rational creature’s natural inclinations. As all living things naturally seek to remain alive, the preservation of life and the production and upbringing of offspring are precepts of the natural law. Furthermore, man, by nature of being a rational creature, seeks to pursue truths about God and to live in society with others. This list of natural law’s precepts is not exhaustive, but, like the ones listed, all precepts of natural law relate to the natural inclinations of rational creatures (Regan,…

    • 1842 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In this essay, I will refute the statement that there is natural duty to obey the law even in reasonably decent democratic societies in order to rescue others from the dangerous conditions of the state of nature. To do this, I will explore a world in which there is a natural duty to obey the law to evaluate if it is the best way to protect us from the dangerous conditions. Next, I will explore the ambiguity in the natural theory to sufficiently justified a duty to obey the law simply because it is a law. Through these analyses, I will address the more important question: under a recent democratic society, what kind of duty do we have to obey the law?…

    • 2080 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Natural law is a theory that if we use reason, we can apply an eternal and absolute moral law. Aquinas believed that the application of this law can help us discover our purpose and achieve it while producing a perfect world. However there are those who believe that natural law can often create controversy and defy common sense.…

    • 519 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics