Preview

Analysis of John Gatto's Article on Educational Reform

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
469 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Analysis of John Gatto's Article on Educational Reform
John Gatto uses many persuasive techniques to try and convince the reader that the reform of schools is necessary. He begins by including the audience that he is talking to in his ‘speech like’ manner “I accept this award on behalf of all of the fine teachers I’ve known over the years” this establishes personal contact with the audience and develops an appropriate register, therefore persuading them to agree with any further comments that he makes. To further support this, the writer goes on to suggest that teachers are not the problem, as he sees it, but school as an institution “although teachers do care and do work very hard, the institution they work in is psychopathic”.
The writer uses the present tense throughout the entire article to highlight the immediacy of the situation and convince the reader that reform is needed.
Gatto’s use of repetition of words like “useless” and “absurd” are used part way through the text in order to not only make a more forceful point, but also to emphasise the way that he feels. By repeating these negatively charged words he is attempting to influence the way reader would feel about education, therefore persuading them that reform is a necessity.
He establishes the idea that reform is necessary with use of a rhetorical question “What can be done?” to not only guide the reader towards a solution but also to indicate that he will be offering a solution that the reader will agree with.
Gatto uses the structure of short sentences in order to develop his argument and focus on key points, almost like a list – a way of simplifying his ideas. A single short sentence is further used “ Schools are intended to produce formulaic human beings whose behaviour can be predicted and controlled.” to enhance the writer’s view about schools, therefore strengthening his argument and persuading his readership to agree that reform is wholly necessary. The use of the word ‘intended’ coupled with ‘formulaic, predicted and controlled’ to describe

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    This chapter focused on the subject and the tenses. To argue, you need an issue. Blame, value, and choice are usually the main causes for an argument. Knowing the issue is important because your goal will not be met if you argue about the wrong core issue. To figure out the core issue, focus on the tense. Blaming is told in past tense, values are in the present, and choice is determined in the future. Control the issue and control the clock. In the present tense (demonstrative) it ends with people separating or bonding. Past tense (forensic) threatens punishment. And future tense (deliberative) argument promises something in the future. He also introduces the first rule of rhetoric, never debate the undebatable.…

    • 2276 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The author of “Against School” John Taylor Gatto believes that during his long career in public schools he didn’t realise that schools are playing any major role in modification of “raw” children except making them childish adults. And the key problem behind the outcome is boredom, it occurs because scholars feel confined in 12 years of “imprisonment”. Gatto thinks that schools can increase the chances of success for their students if they let them make own decisions and take risks when necessary.…

    • 459 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gatto asks if our school system is designed to make sure children never really grow up, and if we really need forced schooling. He compares our school system to Prussian culture: an educational system deliberately made to produce mediocre intellects. Gatto states that in this country people sees “success” as synonymous with “schooling”. He articulates that important people like George Washington, Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, and Abraham Lincoln never went through the twelve-year schooling system we have now and they still succeeded. Gatto said that according to our cultural traditions schools were made to make good people, good citizens, and each person their personal best.…

    • 533 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Fake and gay. Most people would have the same sentiment about the primary and secondary school systems in America. While the argument against the public school system is often presented to the masses in segmented bits and pieces, John Taylor Gatto attacks the meat of the issue in his essay, “Against School.” A retired teacher of thirty years, he engages readers in a conversational dialogue and outlines the ways the educational system fails to address the age-old question: how do I reach these kids? It turns out that the solution is not to try to reach these kids, but to make these kids reach for the knowledge themselves. By differentiating between the definitions of…

    • 935 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The first thing that Gatto does is put ethos to play by establishing this credibility with the audience in a number of ways. Before stating any of his claims against school, he thoughtfully informs his readers of his experience in the educational field in order to add more weight to his words. Not only had Gatto been a teacher for thirty years, but he also was elected New York City Teacher of the Year three times during that period and published a plethora of books on the subject of education. Without having specified this at the very start of his argument, Gatto could have failed to captivate his audience the way he had intended. A lack of expertise, whether it is because that expertise does not exist or because it simply was not made clear, could potentially harm any argument. This is especially the case when making marks against something like the educational system because a majority of the population is by default inclined to support such an…

    • 1386 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    John Gatto Against School

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages

    John Taylor Gatto in his essay “Against School” begins explaining of how boring school is to students. He also explains the damage that the system makes to the teacher and the student by not making the material interesting in class. Furthermore, he explains how the students used to look at him as an incompetent teacher who lacks of knowledge. In addition, he shows the dark side of a school system that intends to brainwash and destroy the ideas from kids. He addresses the main goal of the educational system to convert juveniles into the next docile and manageable generation. Also, he proposes how an educational system should be structured. In addition, he demonstrates how a person can become successful without going to a school…

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “Against School,” John Gato explains that there’s something wrong with the education system along with the process of schooling. In my response, I understand where he’s coming from. I’ve been contemplating myself as to how my twelve years of education had been. I personally agree to his arguments against the education system and public education. I believe what Gato is saying that the educational system and schooling has an issue involving the control and predictability of children.…

    • 480 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The essay 'The Role of the Teacher' written by Irving Layton reviews the current state of our ever criticized school system. The author shows us how we view the problems of the school system and explains how and why we place blame on teachers. He shows how 'penny-pinching school boards'(p145) are the real ones to blame and not the teaches whom are the easiest to confront. 'A feeling has grown that schools and universities are not achieving that which they were intended: namely , the enrichment of the individuals life by giving him the tools of self improvement and the cultivated mind to use them'(p145) is how most people view the school board and what the author is trying to discuss. The author uses a logical pattern and an expository purpose. The author uses opinion based format for this essay.…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He even states, “…I had more than enough reason to think of our schools – with their long-term, cell-block-styles, forced confinement of both students and teachers – as virtual factories of childishness.” (pg. 115). I happen to agree with Gatto. The way most of America’s public schools are even architecturally built, look like prisons! I believe that if schools are built to be perceived as confining, that they pre-establish in students minds that they are meant to think and do exactly as they are told. This diminishes students’ imagination and creative side, conforming our society. Gatto says mass schooling only has three purposes, to make good people, citizens, and each person their personal best to what the school and government seem fit. I strongly agree with Gatto when he professes, “We could encourage the best qualities of youthfulness – curiosity, adventure, resilience, the capacity for surprising insight – simply by being more flexible…” (pg.…

    • 741 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    What is the purpose of the Educational System? Should mankind really be oppressed by the predisposed standards that previous generations have set for the coming ones? Is it logical and fair to give children a set standard of 12 years of school, 6 classes a day, and five days a week? After all, weren’t some of the most successful people throughout history non-graduates of merely secondary schools? According to Gatto’s three-fold purpose of schooling, the main reasons are due to 1) To make good people, 2) To make good citizens, and 3) to make each person his or her best. These three vague expectations of students as a result of the pre-set educational system are actually seen as contradicting the reality of the educational process. Inglis then goes on to break down the schooling process into six basic functions. Three main functions discussed by Gatto are diagnostic and directive functions. Then there is the differentiating function, and finally there is the propaedeutic function. Some of these three functions listed are true and can be related to my own life experiences, however others seem to be merely out of line and completely irrational propositions made by Gatto.…

    • 1008 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    John Gatto, a school teacher in the Manhattan area, taught for thirty years at a variety of different schools. During these years, he realized that children were frequently bored with classroom activities as a result of how they were being taught. Students were not being challenged and often already knew the concepts behind the materials taught. Jean Anyon further supports and agrees with Gatto’s statements about the public school system. In her article, she specifies that schools in wealthy communities are far better than those of poorer communities, and they better prepare children for desirable jobs. Anyon concluded these finding by investigating schools in four different social classes, ranging from working class to executive elite schools.…

    • 2556 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Such small concept such as boredom is ruining modern day schooling, according to Gatto. He starts off by how boredom overpowered the teachers and the students. Teachers are tired of students who are unwilling to learn, and students believe that teachers are unenthusiastic to teach. But Gatto believes that, mainly because he was influenced by his grandfather, that state of boredom has to be blamed on oneself, not others. And people who cannot handle the boredom are childish adults. This means that the way school is set up is already wrong. Unmotivated teacher and students in the school means failure to teach, meaning the function of the school is gone. “If we wanted to we could easily and inexpensively jettison the old, stupid structures and help kids take an education rather than merely receive a schooling … But we don’t do that.” He denounces the current system, and also knows what is needed to be done. It’s true. Many of the teachers are not motivated to teach; it seems that they are waiting for their payday. Students are not motivated also – countless repeats of same concept, set academics - it seems even weird to be motivated. Gatto only uses logic to persuade the audience. All the evidence seems logical, and it seems morally right. Then he asks, “Do we really need school? I don’t mean education, just forced schooling: six classes a…

    • 850 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The author then suggests that maybe that there is not a "problem" with the schools. That they were right when they designed the school to do just what they are doing. Designed not to teach us but to keep us from ever really growing up. With that thought the author asks "do we need school?" Gatto gives us example of well known people who have accomplished great things in their life time but were not educated through the school system.…

    • 869 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Education Analysis Paper

    • 1436 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Gregory Michie succeeds admirably in rendering his teaching experiences in the complicated reality between two extremes in his book Holler If You Hear Me: The Education of a Teacher and His Students. Many people hear about the horror stories, portrayed by the media mainly, that schools in urban America are nothing short of chaos; uneducated and uninterested kids. Then there are other stories that are rarely heard of, about the one teacher who makes the difference in such a school. Michie’s account in his book skillfully avoids the simplification either extreme would demand.…

    • 1436 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    John Gatto, who is the author of “How public education cripples our kids, and why”, shares his insight and experience about schooling. He talks about his experience as a school teacher and how bored not just the students are during school, but the teachers as well. Throughout the beginning of his article he questions himself why is schooling so boring and who is to blame. He believed that boredom and childishness wasn’t a natural state in classrooms and defied such customs by extents to even bend the law (Gatto).…

    • 1578 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays